Collection: Custom Wedding Cookies

When planning a wedding that reflects your unique love story, Custom Wedding Cookies from Taylor Chip offer a personalized and delicious way to celebrate, making your special day even more memorable with beautifully designed, handcrafted treats for guests to enjoy.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

58 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

58 of 58 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

58 products

Based on 1564 reviews
79%
(1235)
8%
(129)
7%
(102)
2%
(36)
4%
(62)
Best Cookies on the market

Have had them in Hershey when visiting my son and just ordered to have them shipped. Will make you never have Crumble again. Cinnamon Roll is my favorite but all of the Peanut butter ones are awesome. Loved the snickerdoodle and Oreo also. The peanut butter and jelly was surprising good also. Quick shipping over the holiday.

Great as always

Love these cookies. I may need to go to rehab :-)

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kendall Gaddis

Great cookies!!

I have been wanting to try Taylor Chip cookies for over a year after constantly seeing them pop up on social media, so I finally ordered a dozen to share with my family for our holiday get-together. I ordered a dozen cookies in 6 different flavors, and the only "flavor" we could taste was the overwhelming taste of sugar. We cut the cookies in 4s on the day of so they stayed wrapped and fresh until just before we ate them, and all 7 of us agreed that they were lacking in flavor and not worth the money or the calories. I was craving mint chocolate all season and was really looking forward to trying the chocolate peppermint cookie but it was just an sugar and didn't taste much different to the snickerdoodle or the regular chocolate chip and so on. I'm really disappointed because I really wanted to like them and feel like it was a waste of money, and I feel like I let my family down by bringing a dessert people didn't really enjoy.

Fantastic Cookies

Choose your own cookies were great. They were all delicious. Favorites were the chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin. Would definitely order again. Everyone agreed they were fabulous and stored well. Loved them!

Good but not great!

Some of the selection were great others were so so.

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Judith E Malavasi
Delicious Cookies

I bought these for a Christmas gift and also got to enjoy. We had to try each flavor that I purchased. What a delicious, soft and fantastic cookie. We had them in the refrigerator and would reheat in microwave for 30 seconds and let it sit before eating. They are so worth the price. Favorite was the Chocolate Chip, Lava, Brownie/Chocolate and Cookies and Cream was the best we ever had. Birthday one was on the sugary side.

Better option than Crumbl

These cookies are good. I do have to say they are pretty sweet and it would be nice if they had half the amount of sugar. I would much rather get Taylor Chip over Crumbl any given day!

I am in love

love the cookies they are such a treat

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Carolyn Stevenson
My Choice

Loved the variety that we could choose from

Best. Cookies. Ever.

Just order them you know you want to! Worth the money and supporting a great company that has a sweet beginning. Cinnamon bun, smores, and oatmeal cream pie are the best! Holiday flavors toasted coconut and white chocolate cranberry 🤌

Wonderful Christmas dessert

All the cookies were delicious and everyone loved them. The favorite was probably oatmeal raisin but they were all wonderful.

Best Cookies EVER!

If it's not Taylor Chip, it's not the best cookies your money can buy. Fast shipping, excellent service and hands down BEST cookies on the planet. I challenge you to find a better cookie anywhere on the planet.

Love It !

I love being able to choose the cookies !

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Christine Kelsey
Choose your own package-delivery

Delicious, decadent cookies. Delivered on time. The whole experience was excellent.
Thank you!

N
Choose Your Own Cookies
Nikole Rotunda
Down home treats that never disappoint!

These are the BEST cookies! We have our favorite flavors but never regret trying new ones. These were a huge hit as surprise Christmas gifts too!

Excellent quality and DELICIOUS

Received my order and the family went wild! I had to hide the box and dole out the cookies!

GF Not the Best

We got the GF cookies as a gift and there were mixed reviews. We were told that the pumpkin cookies were inedible but the chocolate ones were fine. We also couldn't figure out how to add a gift note to the order - doesn't affect the review score, but would be a nice option for future orders.

The cookies are delicious, warmed up made them even better!

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Catherine McKeithen
Excellent!!

Delicious cookies were a huge hit with my cookie loving family!

Xmas gift

Loved them! High quality product. Enjoyed by friends and family.

Addictive

These are amazing love the new holiday cookies.

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Krista Scanlan

They came quickly and were delicious! It was my first time ordering and the discount with free shipping was the push I needed to try them! Everyone enjoyed them at the holidays!

A
Choose Your Own Cookies
Alyssa Kastens
Delicious!

The cookies are delicious! And they freeze well.

Loved everything! Will order again! Great gift!

  • These cookies can be tailored to match your wedding colors, feature initials or dates, and come in various shapes like hearts and flowers. You can choose from a variety of delicious flavors, including vanilla almond, lemon, and chocolate hazelnut, ensuring they cater to all tastes. Complex designs and photo cookies can enhance your wedding's aesthetic appeal. Whether served as favors or displayed on dessert tables, custom cookies add convenience and elegance to your special day. Uncover more about customization and design options next.

    Introduction to Custom Wedding Cookies

    Custom wedding cookies are becoming a popular choice for couples looking to add a personal touch to their celebrations. These cookies offer a unique and customizable alternative to traditional wedding cakes, allowing you to tailor the design and flavor to match your wedding theme perfectly. As more couples prioritize individualized details, custom wedding cookies are emerging as a trendy and delightful option.

    Personalization in Wedding Celebrations

    Personalization has become a hallmark of modern wedding celebrations, allowing couples to infuse their unique style and story into every detail of their special day. One popular way to achieve this is through custom wedding cookies. These delightful treats can be tailored to match your wedding theme, colors, and even feature your initials or wedding date. Fancy cookies for weddings, such as elaborate designs or custom photo cookies, add a personal touch that guests will remember. Incorporating these cookies into your wedding reception not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also offers a sweet, memorable token for your guests. Custom wedding cookies serve as a unique, edible representation of your love story, making your celebration truly one-of-a-kind.

    Growing Trend as Alternative To Traditional Cakes

    As couples seek innovative and personalized touches for their wedding celebrations, the trend of custom wedding cookies is emerging as a charming alternative to traditional cakes. These cookies for weddings offer a unique way to reflect your style and personality. Custom cookies can feature detailed designs, names, dates, and themes, making them a delightful addition to any wedding reception. Wedding cookies come in a wide variety, from elegant royal icing sugar cookies to playful shapes and colors. They can be individually wrapped as favors or beautifully displayed on dessert tables. This growing trend allows for creative versatility, ensuring that every bite is as memorable as your special day. Opting for custom wedding cookies means embracing a modern, personalized twist on a timeless celebration.

    The Appeal of Custom Wedding Cookies

    Custom wedding cookies offer a unique appeal with their variety of flavors and elaborate designs, providing a personalized touch to your celebration. They're versatile and easy to serve, making them a convenient option for guests of all ages. Additionally, their customization options allow you to tailor them to match your wedding theme perfectly.

    Unique Flavors and Designs

    A sense of individuality often shines through in the unique flavors and complex designs of custom wedding cookies. When you choose cookies for a wedding, you can explore a variety of unique flavors that reflect your personal taste and the theme of your wedding reception. These perfect cookies can be as varied and creative as custom wedding cakes, offering something memorable for your guests.

    Consider these enticing options:

    • Lavender and Honey: A gentle, fragrant choice that's both elegant and unique.
    • Lemon and Basil: A invigorating, zesty flavor pairing that surprises and delights.
    • Salted Caramel: A rich, sweet-salty treat that's universally loved.
    • Matcha and White Chocolate: A sophisticated blend for a modern twist.

    Versatility and Ease of Serving

    Beyond their unique flavors and elaborate designs, custom wedding cookies offer unparalleled versatility and ease of serving. They're perfect for a cookies for wedding cookie bar, allowing guests to help themselves without the need for constant supervision. At a cookies for wedding reception, they provide a delightful, mess-free option that's simple to distribute. Wedding congratulations cookies can be beautifully packaged as favors, adding a personal touch to your special wedding events. Placing cookies for wedding cookie table arrangements enhances the aesthetic and provides a practical dessert alternative. Their individual portions make them ideal for guests to enjoy at their convenience, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable experience. Custom wedding cookies truly simplify the catering process while adding elegance and charm to your celebration.

    Customization Options

    One of the biggest appeals of custom wedding cookies lies in their endless customization options. You can work with a custom cake shop to guarantee your cookies match your wedding theme perfectly. Customization options include:

    • Shapes: Hearts, flowers, wedding dresses, and more.
    • Colors: Match your wedding palette with precise color coordination.
    • Flavors: Choose from a variety of flavors to suit your taste.
    • Personalization: Add names, dates, or special messages.

    Unlike a custom baby shower cake or custom birthday cakes, cookies for weddings offer unique flexibility. You can design them to fit any vision, making them an ideal choice. Custom cake pricing varies, so discussing your options with a professional guarantees you get exactly what you want within your budget.

    Types and Varieties

    When it comes to custom wedding cookies, you can choose from a variety of types such as classic sugar cookies, crowd-pleasing chocolate chip cookies, and unique specialty cookies. Each type offers its own flavor profile and decoration possibilities, ensuring your selection aligns with your wedding theme and personal taste. Whether you prefer elaborate icing designs or rich, chewy textures, there's a perfect cookie option for your big day.

    Sugar Cookies

    Sugar cookies are a versatile and beloved choice for custom wedding treats, offering various types and varieties to suit any theme or preference. Their simplicity allows them to be easily customized to match the elegance of wedding cakes or the elaborate cake design of a custom anniversary cake. These cookies can be beautifully placed on reception tables, enhancing the overall aesthetic. Sugar cookies come in various flavors and styles, making them a delightful addition to any wedding.

    • Classic Vanilla: Perfect for those who prefer a traditional flavor of cake.
    • Lemon Zest: Adds a revitalizing twist.
    • Almond: Offers a rich, nutty flavor.
    • Lavender: Provides a unique, floral taste.

    These options guarantee that every guest finds something to love.

    Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Chocolate chip cookies are a timeless favorite that can add a cozy, nostalgic touch to any wedding celebration. They're an excellent addition to your event sweet table, offering a familiar yet delicious treat for guests. For your upcoming wedding reception, consider different variations, such as double chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia, or dark chocolate sea salt. Each type can complement your dream wedding cake, providing a delightful contrast. Additionally, chocolate chip cookies can be customized to match the theme of your custom anniversary cake, making them versatile for any event. Whether you prefer classic recipes or modern twists, these cookies guarantee your special day remains memorable and sweet for everyone involved.

    Specialty Cookies

    Exploring specialty cookies can truly enhance your wedding's dessert table, offering unique and delightful treats beyond the traditional fare. These cookies can be customized to reflect classic wedding cake designs and the theme of your celebration. You might consider these popular types:

    • Macarons: Delicate, colorful, and available in numerous flavors, they're a sophisticated addition.
    • Decorated Sugar Cookies: Personalized with detailed designs, echoing classic wedding cake elements.
    • Gourmet Flavors: Think lavender honey or matcha, appealing to adventurous palates.
    • Cake-Inspired Cookies: Replicating amazing cakes in cookie form, crafted by talented cake fairies.

    These specialty cookies can be tailored to match cake requests and even serve as a delicious custom anniversary cake option, ensuring your dessert table is unforgettable.

    Creative Incorporation Ideas

    You can incorporate custom wedding cookies into various aspects of your celebration to add a personal touch and delight your guests. Use them as charming bridal shower or engagement party treats, elegant wedding favors, or as a delicious addition to your dessert table. Each setting allows these cookies to shine, enhancing the overall experience with unique, edible art.

    Bridal Showers and Engagement Parties

    When planning bridal showers and engagement parties, custom wedding cookies can be a delightful and memorable addition. These charming treats not only enhance the aesthetic but also provide a sweet treat for guests. Consider placing them alongside the classic cake to create a stunning dessert display. Custom wedding cookies can be tailored to match the theme, colors, and even personal preferences of the bride and groom, making each event uniquely special.

    Here are some creative incorporation ideas:

    • Cookie Decor: Design cookies to match the bridal shower or engagement party theme.
    • Personalization: Include the couple's initials or wedding date on the cookies.
    • Guest Gifts: Offer individually wrapped cookies as take-home treats.
    • Table Setup: Arrange cookies around the table with the cake for a cohesive look.

    Wedding Favors

    While planning your wedding, don't underestimate the impact of thoughtful wedding favors. Custom wedding cookies offer a personalized touch that guests will remember. These unique treats can be tailored to match your theme, from elegant designs to fun, whimsical shapes. Unlike traditional cakes to birthday cakes, custom cookies provide a versatile option for any event, including corporate events, baby showers, and, of course, weddings. You can package these cookies in beautiful boxes or bags, making them a memorable takeaway. Additionally, incorporating your monogram or wedding date adds a special touch. Custom wedding cookies not only serve as a sweet treat but also as a token of appreciation, leaving a lasting impression on your guests.

    Dessert Tables

    Custom wedding cookies not only make incredible wedding favors but can also enhance your dessert table to new heights. Imagine pairing elegant, hand-decorated cookies with your other dessert offerings to create a visually stunning and delicious experience. Incorporate your custom cookies creatively alongside:

    • Almond raspberry cake: Complement the nutty and fruity flavors with matching cookie designs.
    • Carrot cake: Use cookies shaped like carrots or with a similar spice profile.
    • Cake sketch: Design cookies that mimic the artistic elements of your cake sketch.
    • Themed displays: Arrange cookies around your central cake to create a cohesive dessert table theme.

    These ideas guarantee that your dessert table is both visually appealing and tantalizing to the taste buds, making your wedding day even more memorable.

    Designing Your Custom Wedding Cookies

    When it comes to designing your custom wedding cookies, start by choosing a baker whose style aligns with your vision. Next, work closely with them through the design process to guarantee your cookies reflect your wedding theme and personal tastes. Finally, don't forget to select flavors that will delight your guests and complement your overall menu.

    Choosing a Baker

    Finding the right baker is essential to guaranteeing your custom wedding cookies are as beautiful as they are delicious. Start by researching local bakers who specialize in custom designs and have experience with wedding events. Look through their portfolios to evaluate their style and craftsmanship. Don't hesitate to schedule consultations to discuss your vision and taste their creations.

    Consider these factors when choosing your baker:

    • Reputation: Read reviews and ask for references from previous clients.
    • Specialization: Verify they have expertise in wedding cookies and custom designs.
    • Availability: Check their schedule and book well in advance to secure your date.
    • Price: Compare quotes to find a balance between quality and budget.

    Choosing the right baker will set the stage for stunning, delectable wedding cookies.

    Design Process

    Initiating the design process for your custom wedding cookies, you'll start by envisioning the perfect blend of aesthetics and flavor that complements your wedding theme. Consider elements like your color palette, floral arrangements, and overall style, whether it's vintage, modern, or rustic. Collaborate with your chosen baker, sharing inspiration photos and specific details you'd like to incorporate, such as monograms, wedding dates, or elaborate patterns. Discuss the cookie shapes, from classic circles and hearts to more unique forms that reflect your wedding's character. It's also essential to decide on the icing type—royal icing offers a smooth, professional finish, while fondant provides a more sculptural, detailed look. By focusing on these design aspects, you'll create cookies that are both visually stunning and meaningful.

    Flavor Selection

    Choosing the right flavors for your custom wedding cookies is a delightful part of the design process. This decision can enhance the experience for your guests, leaving them with memorable and delicious treats. When selecting flavors, consider options that reflect your personality and theme. You might opt for a classic favorite or something a bit more adventurous.

    • Vanilla Almond: A timeless choice that pairs well with various decorations and appeals to many palates.
    • Lemon: Offers a revitalizing, tangy flavor, perfect for spring or summer weddings.
    • Chocolate Hazelnut: Rich and indulgent, ideal for those who love a deeper, nutty taste.
    • Lavender Honey: Unique and elegant, providing a floral note that's both sophisticated and delightful.

    These options guarantee your cookies are as memorable as your special day.

    Practical Considerations

    When considering custom wedding cookies, it's important to think about your budget and ordering timeline. You should determine how much you're willing to spend per cookie and make sure it aligns with your overall wedding budget. Additionally, placing your order well in advance is vital to guarantee availability and allow time for any necessary adjustments.

    Budgeting

    Planning for custom wedding cookies requires careful budgeting to guarantee you get the most value without overspending. First, determine how many guests you'll have and decide on a per-person cookie allotment. Next, research various bakeries to compare prices and quality, ensuring you get the best deal. Remember, customization can add to the cost, so be clear about your design preferences and budget constraints from the start. Finally, consider additional expenses like packaging and delivery fees, which can quickly add up.

    • Estimate guest count and cookie needs
    • Compare multiple bakery quotes
    • Clarify design preferences and budget limits
    • Account for packaging and delivery costs

    Ordering Timeline

    To guarantee your custom wedding cookies arrive fresh and on time, it's crucial to establish a well-planned ordering timeline. Start by contacting your preferred bakery at least three to four months before your wedding date. This allows ample time for consultations, design approvals, and scheduling. Once your design is finalized, place your order no later than six weeks in advance. This buffer guarantees the bakery can source any special ingredients and accommodate unexpected delays. Confirm the delivery date and method two weeks before the wedding to avoid last-minute surprises. If you're ordering from an out-of-town bakery, factor in shipping time and potential transit delays. By planning ahead, you guarantee your cookies are a delightful and timely addition to your special day.

    To sum up, custom wedding cookies offer a unique and memorable touch to your special day, blending both personal sentiment and delectable taste. By carefully considering your design, incorporating creative ideas, and addressing practical aspects, you can create cookies that not only look stunning but also enhance the overall wedding experience. With their versatility and charm, custom wedding cookies are a delightful addition that guests will surely appreciate and remember fondly.