Background Image text here

Choose Your Own Cookies

With almost 30 flavors to choose from, you can make your box as unique as you are.

One Dozen

Twelve 5.5-6oz cookies

$68.94 | $1.01/oz

Select Flavors

Half Dozen

Six 5.5-6oz cookies

$49.97 | $1.47/oz

Select Flavors
Choose Your Cookies for Subscription

Note: Vegan-friendly and gluten-friendly cookies have an upcharge of $1 per cookie. Apple pie cookies have an upcharge of $2 due to the quality of ingredients and unique process we use to make this cookie. Become a member to save $1 on each Vegan, Gluten Free, and the Apple Pie cookies.

Limited Holiday Flavor S'mores Cookie

S'mores Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie

Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Lava Cake Cookie

Lava Cake Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Peppermint Mocha Cookie

Peppermint Mocha Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Birthday Cake Cookie

Birthday Cake Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gluten-Friendly & Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Gluten-Friendly & Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Brownie Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Brownie Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor High 5 Cookie

High 5 Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Cinnamon Bun Cookie

Cinnamon Bun Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor PB Explosion Cookie

PB Explosion Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Brookie Cookie

Brookie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Chocolate Chip Biscuit Cookie

Chocolate Chip Biscuit Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gluten-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Gluten-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gluten-Friendly Brookie Cookie

Gluten-Friendly Brookie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gluten-Friendly Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Gluten-Friendly Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Cookies & Cream Cookie

Cookies & Cream Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie

Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookie

Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Snickerdoodle Cookie

Snickerdoodle Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Cookies & Cream Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Cookies & Cream Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Sugar Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Sugar Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Brookie Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Brookie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Vegan-Friendly Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Vegan-Friendly Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Gingersnap Cookie

Gingersnap Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Toasted Coconut Cookie

Toasted Coconut Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Carrot Cake Cookie

Carrot Cake Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Lemon Lavender Cookie

Lemon Lavender Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Spicy Salted Cocoa Cookie

Spicy Salted Cocoa Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Sugar Cookie

Sugar Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Walnut Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Walnut Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie

Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Kitchen Sink Cookie

Kitchen Sink Cookie

Member's Exclusive! Limited Holiday Flavor Doug’s Fluffernutter Cookie

Doug’s Fluffernutter Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Peanut Butter Blossom

Peanut Butter Blossom

Limited Holiday Flavor White Chocolate Cranberry

White Chocolate Cranberry

Limited Holiday Flavor Maple Chai

Maple Chai

Limited Holiday Flavor Soft Sugar Cookie

Soft Sugar Cookie

Limited Holiday Flavor Andy's Candy

Andy's Candy

Your ½ dozen is ready!

SAVE 31% when you upgrade to a dozen!

Upgrade To Dozen
No thanks!

Don't pass up on this offer!

Are you sure you don't want to upgrade and save 15%?!

No thanks!

You have succcesfully added box of cookies to your cart.

New Choose Your Own. continue shopping
You picked 0 cookie(s) out of Clear cookies
Add to cart
Speacial Cookie Price
Default Alt Text

Hey Cookie Lover,

Join the Cookie Club!

Looks like the cookie club might be just right for you! Join our membership and get access some of our exclusive features:

  • 20% Discount site-wide as a member
  • Monthly Dozen Included
  • Always FREE Shipping on all your orders
  • Unlock exclusive cookies
  • Pause or Cancel Anytime
  • Seamlessly gift your monthly included dozen
Join the club! Learn more

You might also be interested in...

Everyone’s Favorite Cookie Bundle

Everyone’s Favorite Cookie Bundle

We’ve taken the guess work out of your selection process and picked out the most...

The Most Chocolatey Cookie Bundle

The Most Chocolatey Cookie Bundle

If you LOVE chocolate and aren’t afraid of some cookies with nuts in them then...

Gluten-Friendly Cookie Bundle

Gluten-Friendly Cookie Bundle

Our Free from gluten cookies are made with our own blend of minimally processed flour...

View More