Peanut Butter Cookies

We're kicking off with our Peanut Butter Cookies, each packed with natural, 100% American peanuts that bring out the rich, authentic flavors nut lovers crave. Combining creamy and crunchy peanut...

Choose Your Own Cookies

Choose Your Own Cookies

Everything Nutty Cookie Bundle

Truly something to go nuts over, our “Everything Nutty” assortment is exactly what a nut...

Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie

When you’re craving a decadent treat that combines the creaminess of peanut butter with the...

Vegan-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

When you want a rich and satisfying treat packed with bold peanut butter flavor, our...

PB Explosion Cookie

This Hershey exclusive is an explosion of all the best peanut butter candies with every...

Sara’s Fluffernutter Cookie

Everyone’s childhood dream in cookie form. Made with an all-natural, locally made, peanut butter, filled...

Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie

Get ready for the ultimate cookie mashup with our Cookie Club exclusive flavor Peanut Butter...

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

When you’re craving the nostalgic combination of peanut butter and sweet fruit jam, our bakers...

High 5 Cookie

Inspired by a popular candy bar (Take 5), we like to say it’s one heck...

Doug’s Fluffernutter Cookie

A Fluffernutter like cookie with a twist. The dough is mixed with 30lbs of an...

Brownie Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

When you're looking for the perfect combination of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter, our...

Gluten-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Our Free From Gluten Loaded Peanut Butter cookie is made with our own blend of...

Based on 1604 reviews
79%
(1263)
8%
(133)
6%
(103)
2%
(39)
4%
(66)

It was good

H
Choose Your Own Cookies
Holly E Holleran
Fab!!

The best ever!!

They were good but they all tasted the same to me.

m
Choose Your Own Cookies
manning, james

well done as usual..

Delicious

I really enjoyed the variety, freshness and quality of your cookies. It was my first time trying them but wont b my last.

Very good but spendy

I thought the cookies were very good but are too expensive for my taste. Would need a hefty discount to buy them again. Plus they screwed up my order so they owe me for two cookies.

S
Choose Your Own Cookies
Stephanie Thompson
Amazing

Absolutely love these cookies. I’ve wanted to order them for a long time but living in florida I waited until winter so they wouldn’t melt too much on the trip. They taste amazing warmed up too. the cookies and cream didn’t have cream but it still tasted great. Fluffernutter barely had fluff. I didn’t think there was any but my husband found a smidge. I would suggest more fluff please. Definitely will be ordering more.

B
Choose Your Own Cookies
Brian Garnhart
Great cookies!

Tasty! Great variety! Came in great condition!

M
The Cookie Club
Marjorie Diaco
Cookies

Love the cookies bc I love the variety you can get and they're soft and chewy. Love them that way

Probably the best cookies I've ever eaten. The ginger snap is my absolute favorite - the spice is perfect! I love that when you order a dozen, you can choose which flavors you want. Definitely will order again.

T
Choose Your Own Cookies
Todd Guldenschuh

Every different cookie is delicious!

Love them! Wonderful texture and flavor. Very reasonably priced.

Amazing!!

Taylor Chips cookies are absolutely amazing! Allows you to choose your own but trust me, they're all delicious. I heat in microwave for 30 seconds and "perfecto". Delivery is fast with communication from TC of progress and tracking info. I always order 2 dozen; one for the office and the other all mine, lol!

Amazing As Always!

My favorite cookies! I love that they are ditching all the dyes & only use ingredients we would use at home! Sooooo yummy too!

These cookies are amazing!

I ordered 6 different kinds of cookies and each one is more delicious than the last.

E
Holiday Cookie Bundle
Elaine Villareale

Best cookies next to homemade. Flavors are on point. Just placed my 3rd order, so yes, they are that good!. Support small/local businesses.

Great Cookies

While I can't afford to indulge in these cookies too often (weight related) they are awesome for a treat and to share with friends. When you consider the size and quality of the cookies, they really are not a bad value. My favorite is Peanut Butter Fudge, but I honestly haven't tried a flavor that wasn't good. I will definitely continue to order for special occasions and just for the occasional splurge.

Good cookies

Yummy. I liked the holiday flavors.

Always a hit!

Can not get it wrong when you order from Taylor Chips. Delivered on time and packaged so they arrive in great shape and always delicious !

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kelly Gagliardi
Yum

I’ve tried 3 of the cookies I ordered & and they are all great!! The snickerdoodle is my favorite 🤩

Yummy in the tummy ordered 6 and ate them in 6 days they are delicious beyond words

The cookies are so delicious beyond words ordered 6 and ate one everyday all gone now and doctor wants to me to gain weight do to my cancer and honestly they seem to be the only thing i can eat

Best cookie

Took these to my family‘s house for Christmas celebration everyone love them

All Went Well

The order went smooth, the package arrived as scheduled and most important… The cookies were delicious.

Amazing cookies as always

Ordered a half dozen back in 2020 a few times. Forgot about them and placed another order in 2024 - still as great as always. Every single flavor has been a hit, and these are still the best cookies I have ever tried. Other companies like Bang or Crumbl are good in their own right but I genuinely believe Taylor Chip is a tier above and by itself.

-Sean aka "Cookie Monster"

u
Choose Your Own Cookies
utsav hasmukh patel
Great cookies

The peppermint mocha and double chocolate cookies were excellent.