Collection: Peanut Butter Cookies

We're kicking off with our Peanut Butter Cookies, each packed with natural, 100% American peanuts that bring out the rich, authentic flavors nut lovers crave. Combining creamy and crunchy peanut butter with all-purpose flour, brown sugar, and a pinch of salt, we scoop the dough onto parchment-lined baking sheets. After the baking process to golden brown perfection, they're stored in airtight containers to keep them chewy and delicious.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

12 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

12 of 12 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

12 products

Based on 1440 reviews
79%
(1133)
8%
(120)
7%
(96)
2%
(35)
4%
(56)
D
Choose Your Own Cookies
DaMetrius Savage
Cookie Delicious

These cookies were excellent for my first try!! Will be ordering again in near future!!! Much love!!!

Amazing!

Cookies are great, but when you put them in the oven to heat them up, it takes them to the next level!

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Joseph Maniscalco
Delish

The cookies came well packaged and were delicious. A bit pricey but definitely a very good cookie

W
Choose Your Own Cookies
William McCarthy
Awesome!!

The treat that is better than you imagined!

F
Choose Your Own Cookies
Frank Angelino

Great cookies

Thanks

I keep the cookies in freezer to use as a treat. One cookie lasts me 2days. The order arrived promptly and intact. There are flavors I would like to try but I can’t justify becoming a cookie club member

Great cookies. Well worth it

Love Taylor Chip cookies. Especially the various chocolate and peanut butter combinations. Well worth the trouble to get them shipped.

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kristine St John

Most amazing cookies ever. I'm a repeat consumer 4x over. 😊😊

Excellent

One of the best Cookies ever!

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jeffrey Barnhart
LOVE TAYLOR CHIP COOKIES

Awesome experience and finished product

O
The Cookie Club
Oletha Minto
Confusing

I thought a three month subscription stopped after that. Apparently it renews. Also a lot of cookies out of stock

R
Choose Your Own Cookies
Richard Fierro
Damn good cookies!

Great variety, all simply fantastic. Plenty of cookie, not overdone with chocolate chips, peanut butter or raisins, all just right.

10/10 would recommend.

Loved each of the cookies that were shipped. My favorites were the peanut butter fudge and the chocolate chip cookies. Each were very tasty. Good room temperature and warmed up in the microwave. Great cookies and definitely will get again soon!

D
Choose Your Own Cookies
Danielle Mills
Third order

I’ve ordered three times now and visited the Intercourse, PA location twice and I stand by these are the best cookies. My nephew has requested several chocolate cookies for Christmas so I’ll be ordering again for the holidays

E
Choose Your Own Cookies
Elizabeth McClure
Always the best

Pro tip: ALWAYS grab the seasonal or any new flavors on your order, even if they're not what you'd normally reach for. I've had all of the regular flavors, but gravitate towards the cookies with lots of chocolaty mixins, but on my most recent order, I grabbed an oatmeal cream pie (more for my dad than myself) and figured it would join the list of "good but not on the favorites list." But honestly I wish I had ordered a batch of *just* the oatmeal cream Pies. They were perfect and not overly processed tasting like the prepackaged, soggy, flavorless cookies my grandpa used to be obsessed with. Truly, I wish he was still around to try this amazing take on his favorite classic. He would have been obsessed

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Joan McLaughlin
Amazing cookies!

Easy to place an order, received my cookies in perfect order.

We Just Keep On Buying

This is our fourth order and we couldn't be more satisfied with the cookies. The hardest part of our order is deciding what to order quantity-wise out of a dozen. There are just too many good choices to make. Already looking forward to our next order.

Omg…..these cookies are so yummy

Great cookies….soft, fresh, selection is so so good, delivery was fast, and I ate a dozen all by myself!!! My favs: snickerdoodle, chocolate lava and of course the season’s best - pumpkin. They are addicting!

Choose Cookies

I wish we could choose all the flavors.

1/2 dozen cookies!!!

They were all delicious as usual. My favorites are the: white chocolate macadamia nut and the chocolate with oreos and m&m's!!!!! Thank you

They are good but expensive!!

Around $10 a cookie!! Really! They are good but not $70 for half dozen!! Ouch!!!!

These cookies are the best!

My favorite cookie is crunchy on the outside, soft in the middle and these are the bomb! Perfect consistency! I can't even pick a favorite as they are all good! I will definitely reorder to try all flavors!

Mm good

Cookies are awesome. The pumpkin spice was like eating cake, it was delicious. Looking forward to more 😋

Best cookies ever

Ordered a dozen of our favorites!!
Most went in the freezer ...... they freeze extremely well!!! This way we enjoy for the next several weeks.

Great cookies, even better company

I can't say enough good things about this company. The cookies are superb, interesting and taste great- Wonderful gifts
What really separates this company is the extraordinary customer service- in an age when quality customer service is a challenge for many companies, Taylor Chip stands out above the rest in making sure that you are valued as a customer, and the product is excellent.

  • For Peanut Butter Lovers

    Peanut butter enthusiasts will find their cravings fully satisfied with our diverse range of Taylor Chip Peanut Butter Baked Cookies. From the decadent Peanut Butter Fudge to the unique Peanut Butter & Jelly, we've got something for every taste. Don't miss out on our special Fluffernutter varieties, and for those with dietary preferences, check out our Vegan and Gluten-Free options. They're all simply irresistible!

    Cookie Size

    Our cookies stand out not only for their flavors but also for their generous size, with each cookie weighing at least 5.5 ounces. Here's why size matters:

    1. More Satisfaction: Larger cookies mean more enjoyment in each bite.
    2. Perfect for Sharing: Ideal size to split with a friend.
    3. Visual Appeal: A big cookie makes a memorable, Instagram-worthy treat for everyone.

    Dietary Information

    At Taylor Chip, we are dedicated to providing a variety of dietary options including nut-free, gluten-free, vegan, and dairy-free cookies, although our kitchen does process common allergens. We're committed to inclusivity, so everyone can enjoy our treats regardless of dietary restrictions. We always aim to be transparent about our dry ingredients, ensuring you can indulge without worry. Choose your favorite, knowing we've got your dietary needs covered!

    Freshness and Quality

    While we prioritize a variety of dietary options, we equally focus on ensuring every cookie is crafted with the utmost freshness and high-quality simple ingredients. Here's what sets our cookies apart:

    1. Handmade Daily: Ensuring peak freshness
    2. Select Ingredients: Only the finest materials
    3. Consistent Checks: Regular quality control

    We're committed to delivering the freshest, most delicious peanut butter cookies you've ever tasted!

    Baked and Shipped Same Day

    We bake and ship your favorite cookies on the same day to guarantee maximum freshness. By ensuring they're oven-fresh when they leave our kitchen, you'll experience the ultimate taste and texture. It's our way of making sure that each bite you take is as perfect as the last. Enjoy our commitment to quality, from our oven to your doorstep.

    Express Shipping

    To guarantee your cookies arrive as freshly baked as possible, our express shipping option gets them to you quickly. Here's why it's great:

    1. Speed: Your treats arrive in record time.
    2. Freshness: Less transit time means fresher cookies.
    3. Convenience: Quick, hassle-free delivery right to your doorstep.

    We're committed to ensuring you get the best, most delicious experience with every order!

    We're excited for you to try our Taylor Chip Peanut Butter Cookies, whether you're a peanut butter purist or crave something unique like our PB Nutella. Each cookie, crafted daily and loaded with 100% American peanuts, promises freshness and quality. With options for all, including vegan and gluten-free, we've got something for every cookie enthusiast. Don't hesitate any longer; indulge in this nutty delight and experience the perfect blend of health and tast