Collection: Stuffed Cookies

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

53 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

53 of 53 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

53 products

Based on 1440 reviews
79%
(1133)
8%
(120)
7%
(96)
2%
(35)
4%
(56)
D
Choose Your Own Cookies
DaMetrius Savage
Cookie Delicious

These cookies were excellent for my first try!! Will be ordering again in near future!!! Much love!!!

Amazing!

Cookies are great, but when you put them in the oven to heat them up, it takes them to the next level!

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Joseph Maniscalco
Delish

The cookies came well packaged and were delicious. A bit pricey but definitely a very good cookie

W
Choose Your Own Cookies
William McCarthy
Awesome!!

The treat that is better than you imagined!

F
Choose Your Own Cookies
Frank Angelino

Great cookies

Thanks

I keep the cookies in freezer to use as a treat. One cookie lasts me 2days. The order arrived promptly and intact. There are flavors I would like to try but I can’t justify becoming a cookie club member

Great cookies. Well worth it

Love Taylor Chip cookies. Especially the various chocolate and peanut butter combinations. Well worth the trouble to get them shipped.

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kristine St John

Most amazing cookies ever. I'm a repeat consumer 4x over. 😊😊

Excellent

One of the best Cookies ever!

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jeffrey Barnhart
LOVE TAYLOR CHIP COOKIES

Awesome experience and finished product

O
The Cookie Club
Oletha Minto
Confusing

I thought a three month subscription stopped after that. Apparently it renews. Also a lot of cookies out of stock

R
Choose Your Own Cookies
Richard Fierro
Damn good cookies!

Great variety, all simply fantastic. Plenty of cookie, not overdone with chocolate chips, peanut butter or raisins, all just right.

10/10 would recommend.

Loved each of the cookies that were shipped. My favorites were the peanut butter fudge and the chocolate chip cookies. Each were very tasty. Good room temperature and warmed up in the microwave. Great cookies and definitely will get again soon!

D
Choose Your Own Cookies
Danielle Mills
Third order

I’ve ordered three times now and visited the Intercourse, PA location twice and I stand by these are the best cookies. My nephew has requested several chocolate cookies for Christmas so I’ll be ordering again for the holidays

E
Choose Your Own Cookies
Elizabeth McClure
Always the best

Pro tip: ALWAYS grab the seasonal or any new flavors on your order, even if they're not what you'd normally reach for. I've had all of the regular flavors, but gravitate towards the cookies with lots of chocolaty mixins, but on my most recent order, I grabbed an oatmeal cream pie (more for my dad than myself) and figured it would join the list of "good but not on the favorites list." But honestly I wish I had ordered a batch of *just* the oatmeal cream Pies. They were perfect and not overly processed tasting like the prepackaged, soggy, flavorless cookies my grandpa used to be obsessed with. Truly, I wish he was still around to try this amazing take on his favorite classic. He would have been obsessed

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Joan McLaughlin
Amazing cookies!

Easy to place an order, received my cookies in perfect order.

We Just Keep On Buying

This is our fourth order and we couldn't be more satisfied with the cookies. The hardest part of our order is deciding what to order quantity-wise out of a dozen. There are just too many good choices to make. Already looking forward to our next order.

Omg…..these cookies are so yummy

Great cookies….soft, fresh, selection is so so good, delivery was fast, and I ate a dozen all by myself!!! My favs: snickerdoodle, chocolate lava and of course the season’s best - pumpkin. They are addicting!

Choose Cookies

I wish we could choose all the flavors.

1/2 dozen cookies!!!

They were all delicious as usual. My favorites are the: white chocolate macadamia nut and the chocolate with oreos and m&m's!!!!! Thank you

They are good but expensive!!

Around $10 a cookie!! Really! They are good but not $70 for half dozen!! Ouch!!!!

These cookies are the best!

My favorite cookie is crunchy on the outside, soft in the middle and these are the bomb! Perfect consistency! I can't even pick a favorite as they are all good! I will definitely reorder to try all flavors!

Mm good

Cookies are awesome. The pumpkin spice was like eating cake, it was delicious. Looking forward to more 😋

Best cookies ever

Ordered a dozen of our favorites!!
Most went in the freezer ...... they freeze extremely well!!! This way we enjoy for the next several weeks.

Great cookies, even better company

I can't say enough good things about this company. The cookies are superb, interesting and taste great- Wonderful gifts
What really separates this company is the extraordinary customer service- in an age when quality customer service is a challenge for many companies, Taylor Chip stands out above the rest in making sure that you are valued as a customer, and the product is excellent.

  • Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies Category

    We're excited to introduce you to the Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies category, where we've mastered the art of the stuffed cookie. From the decadent brownie peanut butter chip to the festive birthday cake flavor, there's something to satisfy every craving. Each cookie is a hefty 5.5oz of hand-crafted goodness, packed with house-made fillings like chocolate and peanut butter. We prioritize local, straightforward dry ingredients to deliver the freshest, most delightful cookies right to your doorstep. Shipped fast from Intercourse, Pennsylvania, our cookies arrive ready to impress. Curious about more? There's definitely more to uncover.

    Choose Your Own Delightfully Perfect Cookies

    Explore nearly 30 unique flavors, so you can customize your cookie box to perfectly match your taste. Indulge in delectables like brownie peanut butter chip, birthday cake, or s'mores. Crave classics? Try chocolate chip or loaded peanut butter. Fancy a twist? Pick salted caramel pretzel or oreos & cream. For dietary preferences, we've got vegan chocolate chip and gluten-free double chocolate brownie.

    Variety of Flavors

    Our selection of Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies offers an impressive variety of flavors, ensuring there's a perfect match for every palate. From classic chocolate chip to adventurous cookie combinations like peanut butter fudge and brookie, our flavor options cater to all cookie cravings. Explore our stuffed cookies on a cookie tray and discover unique cookie creations and delightful cookie recipes.

    Taylor Chip Process

    After exploring the wide range of timeless flavors, let's look at how Taylor Chip cookies are crafted to guarantee freshness and quality. We kick off our cookie making with stuffed cookie recipes, scooping cake flour and brown sugar into cookie dough balls. Whether it's creamy or natural peanut butter, chocolate chip cookies, or a rich chocolate mixture, each batch is a proof of our dedicated process.

    Shipping

    How quickly can you enjoy the delicious cookie experience once they're ordered? We've got your cravings covered with fast and efficient shipping options:

    1. Same Day Shipping: Orders placed are baked and shipped the same day.
    2. Express Shipping: For when you can't wait.
    3. Unique Box Packaging: Ensuring safe and smile-inducing deliveries.
    4. Shipped from Intercourse, Pennsylvania: Home to our creative flavors and local ingredients.

    Hand-Crafted

    Do you know that each of our cookies is meticulously handcrafted, weighing at least 5.5oz and filled with our house-made toppings? We prioritize using local, simple ingredients to create unique flavors that are truly Pennsylvania's pride. Each batch is baked with smiles and shipped fast via Express Shipping. At Taylor Chip, we're all about hand-crafted quality and delicious, innovative self-care treats!

    Minimum Weight of 5.5oz

    Each of our decadent cookies weighs at least 5.5oz, ensuring a generous and perfect treat every time. Here's a glimpse at our variety:

    1. Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    2. Lava Cake
    3. Sara's Fluffernutter
    4. Birthday Cake

    From the decadent PB Explosion to the unique Kitchen Sink, each flavor celebrates a hearty, indulgent experience. Indulge in a Brownie Peanut Butter Chip or savor the High 5!

    Hand-Filled and Topped

    We also take great care in hand-filling and topping each cookie to enhance its unique flavors and textures. Our 5oz cookies, crafted in Intercourse, Pennsylvania, feature house-made fillings using local ingredients. With nearly 30 flavors, we guarantee fast and express shipping so you can enjoy our hand-crafted, hand-filled cookies with their distinct tastes promptly and freshly.

    Prioritizing Local, Simple Ingredients

    Our dedication to using local, simple ingredients guarantees that every cookie not only tastes homemade but also supports our community. Here's how we do it:

    1. Local Ingredients: Sourced directly from Pennsylvania farmers.
    2. Simple Ingredients: Nothing artificial, just pure goodness.
    3. Hand-Crafted: Each cookie is artisanal, baked with care.
    4. Unique Flavors: House-made fillings bring distinct, delightful tastes.

    We're thrilled for you to explore our world of Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies! Each cookie, from Chocolate Covered Strawberry to Kitchen Sink, is a tribute to our commitment to quality and creativity. Handcrafted in the heart of Intercourse, Pennsylvania, our cookies are not just treats, they're an experience. Choose your box, taste the difference local ingredients make, and enjoy the art of the cookie scene with us. It's not just a flavorful cookie; it's a journey in every bite!