Collection: Stuffed Cookies

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

52 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

52 of 52 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

52 products

Based on 1519 reviews
79%
(1198)
8%
(126)
7%
(99)
2%
(36)
4%
(60)

Awesome

Love them!

Loooooveeee themmmmm!

I love the variety! All of the cookies we've ordered have been wonderful

Yummy

Bought a dozen for me and another dozen as a gift. Cookies taste great and moist. Recommended for cookie lovers.

O
Holiday Cookie Bundle
Odyssey Martin

The cookies are a nicely sized. They were perfectly individually packed. These are Christmas gifts so super happy to try a few and give them out.

These are the best biggest cookies ever. I'm so glad I ordered. So worth it. Really enjoyed them.

Still the best

Great cookies, had em delivered all the way down here to Texas!

The cookies looked amazing but were much too sweet for my liking. It was difficult to taste anything other than sugar. The one exception was the chocolate lava cookie which was delicious with the dark chocolate being the boldest flavor.

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
LAURIE OGG BURNETT
Yummy

Best cookies ! Omg the ginger snap was to die for ❤️

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Wilson-Loving

Delicious & gooey!

Cookies were delicious

Quick, easy, and delicious. Worth every penny.

The best cookies

I live in California so these are always shipped to me. I get them within a week they're package very well, never broken. They are so yummy! I enjoy them as is but can be a little under cooked for some. You can put them in the oven for just a little bit and they cook a bit more and are like freshly baked cookies. Well worth the money.

Christmas gift

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Hawbaker
Delicious as always!

Shipping was prompt. Cookies were all in great shape! Each one was sealed individually, which is great for freshness and freezing! They are all fresh and delicious as always.

Always excellent!!

The cookies are so good. They freeze well which allows you to enjoy them longer.

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Farda
Awesome!!!

These were absolutely delicious, so fresh and such fast shipping!

Yummiest ever cookies

These were delicious. I say "were" cause they did not last long around my home. Shipping was quick also a few days to me. They are pricey but they are not your store bought cookies and if you're not a baker we'll worth the purchase. Absolutely Delicious Thanks Taylor Cookies

Most popular gift!

What a hit these cookies have been with every person I sent them to. I will definitely be a repeat customer. Thanks for making the holidays special for our friends and family!

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Marjorie Graeff
Exactly what I was looking for

Wanted to gift something for Xmas and your cookies were perfect

Good cookies. I just can't afford them.have a good holiday

N
Choose Your Own Cookies
Nicholas Dufault
Still the best cookies, but a little different

The cookies are phenomenal, full stop. I had bought the PB Explosion cookie in the past and it was the greatest dessert I’ve ever had. I ordered more PB Explosion cookies in this order and these cookies were not “mounded” like they were in the last order. They were completely flat and without that heft, it didn’t allow for the gooey cookie center, which was my favorite part. May be the teensiest bit disappointed in that, but they are still the best cookies I’ve ever had.

Delicious!

These cookies are sweet and delicious. Heat them up and you feel like they are freshly homemade, but better because they aren’t burnt! Thick cookie and will replace a meal anyday.

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Carol DeArmitt

Love these. Order them every year for my aunt and uncle in Florida. They love them too

The cookies are all really delicious. The only hard part is deciding which one to try every time we decide to have one, so actually not really a hard thing. . .

  • Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies Category

    We're excited to introduce you to the Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies category, where we've mastered the art of the stuffed cookie. From the decadent brownie peanut butter chip to the festive birthday cake flavor, there's something to satisfy every craving. Each cookie is a hefty 5.5oz of hand-crafted goodness, packed with house-made fillings like chocolate and peanut butter. We prioritize local, straightforward dry ingredients to deliver the freshest, most delightful cookies right to your doorstep. Shipped fast from Intercourse, Pennsylvania, our cookies arrive ready to impress. Curious about more? There's definitely more to uncover.

    Choose Your Own Delightfully Perfect Cookies

    Explore nearly 30 unique flavors, so you can customize your cookie box to perfectly match your taste. Indulge in delectables like brownie peanut butter chip, birthday cake, or s'mores. Crave classics? Try chocolate chip or loaded peanut butter. Fancy a twist? Pick salted caramel pretzel or oreos & cream. For dietary preferences, we've got vegan chocolate chip and gluten-free double chocolate brownie.

    Variety of Flavors

    Our selection of Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies offers an impressive variety of flavors, ensuring there's a perfect match for every palate. From classic chocolate chip to adventurous cookie combinations like peanut butter fudge and brookie, our flavor options cater to all cookie cravings. Explore our stuffed cookies on a cookie tray and discover unique cookie creations and delightful cookie recipes.

    Taylor Chip Process

    After exploring the wide range of timeless flavors, let's look at how Taylor Chip cookies are crafted to guarantee freshness and quality. We kick off our cookie making with stuffed cookie recipes, scooping cake flour and brown sugar into cookie dough balls. Whether it's creamy or natural peanut butter, chocolate chip cookies, or a rich chocolate mixture, each batch is a proof of our dedicated process.

    Shipping

    How quickly can you enjoy the delicious cookie experience once they're ordered? We've got your cravings covered with fast and efficient shipping options:

    1. Same Day Shipping: Orders placed are baked and shipped the same day.
    2. Express Shipping: For when you can't wait.
    3. Unique Box Packaging: Ensuring safe and smile-inducing deliveries.
    4. Shipped from Intercourse, Pennsylvania: Home to our creative flavors and local ingredients.

    Hand-Crafted

    Do you know that each of our cookies is meticulously handcrafted, weighing at least 5.5oz and filled with our house-made toppings? We prioritize using local, simple ingredients to create unique flavors that are truly Pennsylvania's pride. Each batch is baked with smiles and shipped fast via Express Shipping. At Taylor Chip, we're all about hand-crafted quality and delicious, innovative self-care treats!

    Minimum Weight of 5.5oz

    Each of our decadent cookies weighs at least 5.5oz, ensuring a generous and perfect treat every time. Here's a glimpse at our variety:

    1. Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    2. Lava Cake
    3. Sara's Fluffernutter
    4. Birthday Cake

    From the decadent PB Explosion to the unique Kitchen Sink, each flavor celebrates a hearty, indulgent experience. Indulge in a Brownie Peanut Butter Chip or savor the High 5!

    Hand-Filled and Topped

    We also take great care in hand-filling and topping each cookie to enhance its unique flavors and textures. Our 5oz cookies, crafted in Intercourse, Pennsylvania, feature house-made fillings using local ingredients. With nearly 30 flavors, we guarantee fast and express shipping so you can enjoy our hand-crafted, hand-filled cookies with their distinct tastes promptly and freshly.

    Prioritizing Local, Simple Ingredients

    Our dedication to using local, simple ingredients guarantees that every cookie not only tastes homemade but also supports our community. Here's how we do it:

    1. Local Ingredients: Sourced directly from Pennsylvania farmers.
    2. Simple Ingredients: Nothing artificial, just pure goodness.
    3. Hand-Crafted: Each cookie is artisanal, baked with care.
    4. Unique Flavors: House-made fillings bring distinct, delightful tastes.

    We're thrilled for you to explore our world of Taylor Chip Stuffed Cookies! Each cookie, from Chocolate Covered Strawberry to Kitchen Sink, is a tribute to our commitment to quality and creativity. Handcrafted in the heart of Intercourse, Pennsylvania, our cookies are not just treats, they're an experience. Choose your box, taste the difference local ingredients make, and enjoy the art of the cookie scene with us. It's not just a flavorful cookie; it's a journey in every bite!