Best Mail Order Cookies

When you're on the hunt for the best mail order cookies, you should consider more than just satisfying your sweet tooth. Companies that prioritize quality and use all-natural ingredients can enhance your cookie experience to a whole new level. With a variety of classic and gourmet flavors available, there's something to cater to every preference and dietary need. Efficient shipping and secure packaging guarantee your treats arrive fresh and ready to enjoy. Wondering how to make the best choice and what factors you shouldn't overlook?

Customers rate us 4.6/5 based on 1027 reviews.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$
Clear all

61 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

61 of 61 products

Availability
Clear
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$
Clear all

61 products

Categories
  • Birthday Cake Cookie
    Birthday Cake Cookie
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    We wouldn’t want to celebrate our 5 year anniversary any other way then by releasing BIRTHDAY CAKE! A sweet vanilla cookie, packed full with colorful sprinkles AND filled with our house-made vanilla Icing. This cookie has an explosion of cake batter flavor and is better than the funfetti cake we all adored as kids! We have a feeling it will quickly become a Taylor Chip Classic :)

    ----

    test

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Brookie
    Brookie
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Brownie Peanut Butter Chip
    Brownie Peanut Butter Chip
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    Think chocolate, fudge with a peanut butter twist. It’s a killer recipe for the chocolate and peanut butter lovers of the world. The smooth fudgey chocolate base pairs perfectly with the slightly crunchy texture from the peanut butter chips. WARNING: You may even eat the entire batch 😳

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Build Your Own Bundle
    Build Your Own Bundle
    $0.00 USD
    $0.00 USD
    Title
    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
  • Carrot Cake
    Carrot Cake
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    Carrots and spice and everything nice… 

    Welcoming a brand new cookie release just in time for Easter.

    Packed with fresh grated carrots, mixed with several different spices and slathered with our house-made cream cheese glaze. The texture, flavorful notes, and cake-like density make this cookie divine. 

    Even the Easter Bunny said it was egg-cellent

    Disclaimer: Due to the cream cheese glaze, the cookie will arrive very messy within its individual package.

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Chocolate Chip
    Chocolate Chip
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    The cookie that started it all! Inspired by a cookie that was made with vegetable shortening, the goal was to create a cookie that had that same density and thickness but with simple, natural, ingredients. It took us over a year, but we made it even better. Most would say, it’s the best cookie they ever had.

    ----


    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Chocolate Chip Biscuit
    Chocolate Chip Biscuit
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    50% less sugar than our normal cookies and a great option for breakfast! Our biscuit is the perfect blend of cookie biscuit and scone. This is a completely new experience.

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Chocolate Covered Pretzel
    Chocolate Covered Pretzel
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    A twist of salty and sweet… we had this classic in mind for our cookie friends! Crunchy Hammond’s Pretzels mixed with heaps of smooth Wilbur Chocolate Semi-Sweets, this cookie has all the right flavors and textures. The sprinkle of sea salt and drizzle of house made chocolate syrup make this cookie a delight! We like to call this one “The Perfect After Dinner Snack” as it hits all the right cravings 🙂

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    From $49.97 USD
    From $49.97 USD
    Size
    A Mother’s Day exclusive. Inspired by the classic chocolate dipped strawberries. The sweet flavor of fresh made strawberry preserve, mixed with a rich chocolate and finish and a strawberry glaze on top. Our strawberry filling oozes from the core and is made in house each week with no corn syrup or anything yucky. Chocolate Covered Strawberry is decadent and downright PERFECT for mom and grandma for Mother’s Day! Treat the ladies in your life to something special this year, by sharing the Taylor Chip cheer.

    Flavors

    • Chocolate Covered Strawberry
    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
  • Choose Your Own Cookies
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Customize your selection from all flavors.
    From $49.97 USD
    From $49.97 USD
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    Select Cookies
  • Cinnamon Bun
    Cinnamon Bun
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    Ever wondered what would happen if we slapped a cinnamon bun into a Taylor Chip cookie? We took everything you know and love about the traditional moist, sweet, sticky pastry and elevated it with our signature bourbon vanilla glaze!

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Cookie Club Exclusive Bundle
    Cookie Club Exclusive Bundle
    Flavor Details
    From $49.97 USD
    From $49.97 USD
    Size

    Exclusive to the cookie club members.

    Flavors

    • Kitchen Sink
    • Doug’s Fluffernutter
    • Peanut Butter Oreo
    • Spicy Salted Cocoa
    • Walnut Chocolate Chunk
    • Sugar


    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
  • Cookies & Cream
    Cookies & Cream
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    We put in about 4 to 5 Oreos per cookie by blending the Oreos super fine and then dumping a ton in each batch of our Oreos & Cream cookies. Finished off with an Oreo on top and then baked in the oven to perfection.

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Double Chocolate Brownie
    Double Chocolate Brownie
    Flavor Details
    $5.75 USD
    $5.75 USD
    Title

    The perfect blend of cookie and brownie. We put in a double portion of rich, intense dutch processed cocoa and combine that with a copious amount of local chocolate from Lititz, Pennsylvania.

    Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    View Cookie
  • Doug’s Fluffernutter
    Doug’s Fluffernutter
    Flavor Details