Collection: Birthday Cookies

Celebrating milestone birthdays is a cherished tradition, and incorporating custom cookies into these events adds a personal and delightful touch. From a child's first birthday to an octogenarian's 90th, cookies serve as sweet treats and memorable keepsakes. Each stage of life offers unique opportunities to create visually appealing and delicious cookies that reflect the celebrant's personality and interests. This guide explores the joy of personalized cookies for various birthday celebrations, highlighting themes, decoration ideas, and presentation techniques to elevate each occasion.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

59 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

59 of 59 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

59 products

Based on 1519 reviews
79%
(1198)
8%
(126)
7%
(99)
2%
(36)
4%
(60)

Awesome

Love them!

Loooooveeee themmmmm!

I love the variety! All of the cookies we've ordered have been wonderful

Yummy

Bought a dozen for me and another dozen as a gift. Cookies taste great and moist. Recommended for cookie lovers.

O
Holiday Cookie Bundle
Odyssey Martin

The cookies are a nicely sized. They were perfectly individually packed. These are Christmas gifts so super happy to try a few and give them out.

These are the best biggest cookies ever. I'm so glad I ordered. So worth it. Really enjoyed them.

Still the best

Great cookies, had em delivered all the way down here to Texas!

The cookies looked amazing but were much too sweet for my liking. It was difficult to taste anything other than sugar. The one exception was the chocolate lava cookie which was delicious with the dark chocolate being the boldest flavor.

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
LAURIE OGG BURNETT
Yummy

Best cookies ! Omg the ginger snap was to die for ❤️

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Wilson-Loving

Delicious & gooey!

Cookies were delicious

Quick, easy, and delicious. Worth every penny.

The best cookies

I live in California so these are always shipped to me. I get them within a week they're package very well, never broken. They are so yummy! I enjoy them as is but can be a little under cooked for some. You can put them in the oven for just a little bit and they cook a bit more and are like freshly baked cookies. Well worth the money.

Christmas gift

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Hawbaker
Delicious as always!

Shipping was prompt. Cookies were all in great shape! Each one was sealed individually, which is great for freshness and freezing! They are all fresh and delicious as always.

Always excellent!!

The cookies are so good. They freeze well which allows you to enjoy them longer.

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Farda
Awesome!!!

These were absolutely delicious, so fresh and such fast shipping!

Yummiest ever cookies

These were delicious. I say "were" cause they did not last long around my home. Shipping was quick also a few days to me. They are pricey but they are not your store bought cookies and if you're not a baker we'll worth the purchase. Absolutely Delicious Thanks Taylor Cookies

Most popular gift!

What a hit these cookies have been with every person I sent them to. I will definitely be a repeat customer. Thanks for making the holidays special for our friends and family!

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Marjorie Graeff
Exactly what I was looking for

Wanted to gift something for Xmas and your cookies were perfect

Good cookies. I just can't afford them.have a good holiday

N
Choose Your Own Cookies
Nicholas Dufault
Still the best cookies, but a little different

The cookies are phenomenal, full stop. I had bought the PB Explosion cookie in the past and it was the greatest dessert I’ve ever had. I ordered more PB Explosion cookies in this order and these cookies were not “mounded” like they were in the last order. They were completely flat and without that heft, it didn’t allow for the gooey cookie center, which was my favorite part. May be the teensiest bit disappointed in that, but they are still the best cookies I’ve ever had.

Delicious!

These cookies are sweet and delicious. Heat them up and you feel like they are freshly homemade, but better because they aren’t burnt! Thick cookie and will replace a meal anyday.

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Carol DeArmitt

Love these. Order them every year for my aunt and uncle in Florida. They love them too

The cookies are all really delicious. The only hard part is deciding which one to try every time we decide to have one, so actually not really a hard thing. . .

  • 1st Birthday Cookies

    When planning a first birthday celebration, cookies add sweetness and charm to birthday celebrations. Choosing the right birthday cookies involves selecting soft options with themes that resonate with young children, such as animals or favorite characters. Decorating these cookies allows for creativity, ranging from simple icing to intricate designs that impress guests.

    Sugar cookies are a popular choice, easily personalized with names or themes, making them delightful party favors. When selecting cookies, consider child-friendly ingredients and potential allergens, ensuring they are soft and easy to chew. For those with a sweet tooth, white chocolate chips can be a great addition.

    For decoration, start with simple techniques like colorful icing and sprinkles. Personalize cookies with names or fun shapes using cookie cutters to match the party's theme. Incorporating elements like edible glitter and custom shapes will enhance their appeal. You can even create a "Happy Birthday" message using frosted cookies.

    Ultimately, 1st birthday cookies blend taste and aesthetics, making them memorable treats. Thoughtful designs and creative presentation not only make these cookies visually appealing but also add a special touch to the celebration, encapsulating the joy of this milestone. Consider storing them in an airtight container to maintain freshness.

    16th Birthday Cookies

    Personalized cookies can add a delightful touch to a 16th birthday celebration. These treats can be designed to reflect the birthday person's passions, whether through sweet sixteen themes or their hobbies. Creative presentations, like cookie bars or decorative packaging, can enhance the experience.

    Celebrating with cookies makes the event memorable. Options like handmade sugar cookies, nut-free special orders, and visually appealing cookie bouquets can impress guests. Themed cookies—such as sports, music, or fashion—can be customized with initials, favorite colors, and special messages. Birthday cake cookies are also a popular choice.

    For decorating, use vibrant colors and creative techniques. Incorporate personalized designs with royal icing, edible glitter, and markers for messages. Essential baking tips include accurate measurements, using room temperature unsalted butter, and avoiding overmixing to ensure perfect cookies. Prepare a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat for best results.

    When it comes to presentation, consider tiered platters or elegant packaging like clear cellophane bags tied with ribbons. Gift baskets filled with an assortment of birthday cookies make for a perfect birthday gift. Ultimately, these custom cookies enhance the festive atmosphere, making the birthday celebration unforgettable.

    18th Birthday Cookies

    Turning 18 marks the transition from adolescence to adulthood, bringing new responsibilities and freedoms. This milestone is often celebrated with personalized elements, such as custom cookies. These cookies can feature unique designs that reflect the individual's personality, making the event memorable.

    Celebrating with cookies adds a delightful, personalized touch to the occasion. From classic flavors to adventurous options, cookies can be customized by base, shape, and size to fit any birthday theme. Personal touches, like favorite colors and hobbies, enhance their significance. Birthday brownies or Birthday Blondies can be a delicious alternative to traditional cookies.

    When choosing cookies, consider dietary restrictions, ensuring options like gluten-free or vegan are available for all guests. Thoughtful customization, including shapes and colors, can further personalize the treats. For a classic touch, chocolate chip birthday cookies never fail to please.

    Decorating cookies with vibrant icing, sprinkles, and edible glitter can make them visually appealing. Use a paddle attachment when mixing cookie dough for the best texture. Unique packaging, such as gift boxes or favor bags, adds charm and convenience, making each cookie feel special.

    21st Birthday Cookies

    Custom cookies can add a sophisticated and personal touch to a 21st birthday celebration. By reflecting the birthday celebrant's interests, these treats become more than just desserts—they symbolize personal growth and milestones. A 21st birthday is a significant event marking the transition into full adulthood, often celebrated with parties, toasts, and special gifts.

    Cookies are versatile and can be customized in numerous ways to suit the individual's style, using bright colors and designs that match the celebration's decor. Incorporating cookies into the festivities enhances the atmosphere and provides delicious, easy-to-share treats for guests with a sweet tooth. Birthday cookies and happy birthday cookies are popular choices for these occasions.

    Consider setting up a cookie decorating station for guests to personalize their cookies or offering custom cookie favors as sweet takeaways. Cookie cakes also provide a trendy alternative to traditional birthday cakes, combining the fun of cookies with the grandeur of a cake, allowing for custom designs and flavors. You can even create birthday cake cookies or birthday cake bars for a unique twist.

    By incorporating personalized cookies into the celebration, you create memorable experiences for everyone, ensuring that your 21st birthday party is truly unforgettable. Birthday cookie delivery services can make last-minute surprise birthday parties a breeze, offering same-day birthday delivery options for those in need of a quick solution.

    30th Birthday Cookies

    Customized cookies can add a personal touch to a 30th birthday celebration. You can personalize cookies with unique designs, vibrant icing, and custom shapes that reflect the celebrant's interests. Consider using decorative toppings like sprinkles or edible glitter. High-quality ingredients and proper baking techniques are key to delicious results. Packaging options like clear bags or decorative boxes enhance presentation, while tiered trays can showcase your creations at the party.

    Cookies have long played a delightful role in celebrations. For a 30th birthday, consider frosted cookies, cookie delivery, or even a cookie bouquet. Unique designs, fun shapes, and engaging themes can reflect the celebrant's personality. Custom messages like "Happy Birthday" add a special touch, and colorful toppings can enhance visual appeal.

    To ensure the best flavor, use high-quality ingredients such as unsalted butter, granulated sugar, and all-purpose flour. Proper baking techniques, including using a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat, are essential. For presentation, opt for decorative boxes or themed platters to showcase your treats. By exploring creative ideas and thoughtful presentation, your 30th birthday cookies can be memorable treats that enhance the celebration.

    40th Birthday Cookies

    Celebrating a 40th birthday is special, and custom-made cookies can add a memorable touch. Order gourmet cookies shaped like vintage records or classic cars, personalizing them with names, dates, or favorite quotes. Mastering icing techniques, such as piping and flooding, enhances their appeal, while a cohesive color scheme adds visual interest.

    Consider unique designs that reflect the celebrant's interests, along with personalized messages celebrating their achievements. Fun shapes and vibrant colors can evoke nostalgia, while thoughtful inscriptions make the cookies more meaningful. You can even create birthday chocolate bark or birthday brownies for variety.

    Use icing techniques like piping for detailed designs and flooding for smooth surfaces. Choose colors that reflect the celebrant's personality to elevate your cookies. Adding white chocolate chips or birthday cake crumbs can create interesting textures and flavors.

    Creative packaging can enhance your gift. Personalized boxes, colorful ribbons, and clear bags with themed tags make your cookies stand out. Display them on tiered trays or elegant platters, adding decorative elements for visual appeal. Birthday cookie gift baskets are another excellent option for presenting an assortment of birthday cookies.

    By focusing on unique ideas, decorative techniques, and attractive packaging, you can create memorable treats that celebrate this milestone, leaving a lasting impression on all. Store any leftover cookies in an airtight container to maintain freshness.

    50th Birthday Cookies

    Custom cookies can elevate your 50th birthday celebration, transforming your dessert table into a stunning centerpiece. Personalize cookies with unique shapes and elegant stencils that reflect the birthday person's interests. Creative presentation ideas, like tiered trays and decorative jars, enhance visual appeal.

    Consider custom designs such as sports or travel-themed cookies for him and elegant shapes for her. Enhance personalization with names and special messages, and even edible images that showcase cherished memories.

    For presentation, use vibrant packaging, metallic ribbons, and personalized tags to create an eye-catching display. Arranging cookies on tiered stands adds dimension and makes it easy for guests to choose their favorites.

    To ensure perfect cookies, start with a basic dough recipe using butter, sugar, eggs, flour, and baking powder. Chill the dough before baking, use parchment paper for easy cleanup, and monitor baking time closely.

    With unique cookie ideas, creative presentations, and tried-and-true recipes, your 50th birthday celebration will be both delicious and memorable. Embrace the joy of baking, and let cookies shine at the party!

    60th Birthday Cookies

    Custom cookies are a fantastic addition to any 60th birthday celebration, adding a personalized and festive touch. Choose unique shapes like the number '60' or designs reflecting the honoree's interests, such as golf clubs. Personalization options, like names or special messages in icing, enhance the visual appeal of these happy birthday cookies.

    Thoughtful packaging, such as clear boxes with metallic ribbons, can elevate the presentation. These birthday cookies not only serve as delicious treats but also as memorable party favors, celebrating six decades of life. They make the perfect birthday gift for those with a sweet tooth.

    Creative cookie ideas include unique shapes, such as musical notes or favorite animals, along with personalized touches. Mastering icing techniques and adding edible decorations like sprinkles or gold leaf can enhance their visual appeal. Consider using white chocolate chips or colorful sprinkles for extra flair.

    When packaging, consider elegant gift boxes and custom labels to create a special touch. For display at the party, use tiered stands or decorative trays to make them the centerpiece. You can also create gift baskets filled with an assortment of birthday cookies for a more elaborate presentation.

    With careful planning, your 60th birthday cookies will delight guests and add a meaningful touch to the celebration, making it truly unforgettable. These sweet treats are perfect for satisfying any birthday cake craving and can be a delightful alternative to a classic birthday cake.

    70th Birthday Cookies

    Make a 70th birthday memorable with personalized cookies that add joy and creativity to the celebration. These versatile treats can be shaped, flavored, and decorated to match any theme, and they simplify party logistics since they require no utensils, making cleanup easy. They're an excellent option for birthday cookie delivery or as part of birthday packages.

    Custom cookies with names, special dates, or edible images offer a unique touch, while creative packaging options like cellophane bags or decorative tins enhance their presentation. Baking success hinges on accurate ingredient measurement, chilling the dough, and rotating baking sheets for even results. Use a baking sheet lined with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat for best results.

    Cookies are perfect for any birthday celebration due to their convenience and customization options. Incorporate themed designs reflecting the honoree's interests, and consider adding personalized details like colors or quotes to make each cookie special. You can even create birthday cake cookies or birthday brownies for variety.

    To enhance your cookies' presentation, use colorful icing and edible glitter, and package them creatively in elegant boxes or decorative tins. Display your cookies on tiered trays or in clear jars to make them the centerpiece of the event. For long-lasting freshness, store them in an airtight container.

    80th Birthday Cookies

    Personalized cookies are the perfect touch for an 80th birthday, making the event truly memorable. Consider designs that reflect the honoree's interests, such as gardening tools or classic gold and white floral patterns. Personalization adds sentimental value, incorporating favorite colors, names, or significant dates. Using high-quality ingredients and precise baking techniques is essential for the best flavor and texture. Decorative elements like royal icing and edible glitter enhance visual appeal, while elegant packaging, such as vintage-inspired boxes or custom ribbons, raises the presentation.

    Choosing the right cookie design can highlight the milestone age through themes like vintage styles or elegant patterns. Add thoughtful personal touches that resonate with the honoree’s journey, such as their initials or memorable symbols.

    To achieve perfect cookies, focus on essential ingredients like flour, sugar, and butter, and master key baking techniques. Enhance your cookies with creative toppings like edible glitter or colorful sprinkles, and use elegant packaging ideas to create a memorable presentation. With these elements, your 80th birthday cookies will be delightful, meaningful treats that enhance the celebration.

    90th Birthday Cookies

    Custom cookies for a 90th birthday celebration blend taste and visual appeal. Choose popular options like chocolate chip or sugar cookies, ensuring they align with the guest of honor's preferences and dietary needs. Personalize them with names and ages for a heartfelt touch, and consider elaborate designs or edible gold for sophistication. Decorative packaging, like themed boxes or cellophane bags, enhances presentation.

    Cookies have a cherished role in celebrations, especially at a milestone birthday. Popular choices include classic chocolate chip, sugar cookies, and shortbread, easily customizable with decorations. Creative decoration techniques, like using royal icing or edible accents, make each cookie special. Personalizing with the birthday person's name or favorite colors adds meaningful flair.

    For a memorable 90th birthday, consider unique presentation ideas such as decorative tins, glass jars, or themed trays. Stunning packaging with personalized tags and festive bows ensures the cookies are not only delicious but also visually appealing. Thoughtful cookie selection, decoration, and presentation can make the celebration delightful and unforgettable.

    Incorporating custom cookies into birthday celebrations enhances the festive atmosphere, offering a delicious way to commemorate special milestones. Whether it's whimsical designs for a first birthday or elegant presentations for a 50th, personalized cookies create lasting memories for guests and celebrants alike. By focusing on unique designs, high-quality ingredients, and thoughtful packaging, these delightful treats become more than just desserts; they transform into meaningful symbols of celebration, making each birthday truly unforgettable.