The Most Chocolatey
The Most Chocolatey
The Most Chocolatey
The Most Chocolatey
The Most Chocolatey
The Most Chocolatey


The Most Chocolatey

If you LOVE chocolate and aren’t afraid of some cookies with nuts in them then this is the bundle for you! We’ve put together the best chocolate lover’s assortment you are sure to be head over heels for.

Our Delightfully Perfect cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

Flavors:

  • Double Chocolate Brownie
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Brookie
  • Lava Cake
  • Peanut Butter Fudge
  • Oreos & Cream

allergens

Dairy, Eggs, Soy, Cornstarch, Wheat, Peanuts, Nuts
  • Dairy
  • Eggs
  • Soy
  • Cornstarch
  • Wheat
  • Peanuts
  • Nuts


All Taylor Chip™ products are made in a kitchen that also processes dairy, peanuts, tree nuts, gluten, eggs. Although we offer nut free, gluten free, Vegan and dairy free options, we are not an allergen free kitchen.

card image

gid://shopify/MediaImage/33137846157561

flavors

Double Chocolate Brownie, Chocolate Chip, Brookie, Lava Cake, Peanut Butter Fudge, Oreos & Cream
Double Chocolate Brownie
Double Chocolate Brownie

The perfect blend of cookie and brownie. We put in a double portion of rich, intense dutch processed cocoa and combine that with a copious amount of local chocolate from Lititz, Pennsylvania.

Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip

The cookie that started it all! Inspired by a cookie that was made with vegetable shortening, the goal was to create a cookie that had that same density and thickness but with simple, natural, ingredients. It took us over a year, but we made it even better. Most would say, it’s the best cookie they ever had.

Brookie
Brookie

The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

Lava Cake
Lava Cake

Just like your favorite dessert, but in cookie form! A more cake-like double chocolate brownie cookie filled with a homemade hot fudge filling, and topped with powdered sugar. Our most chocolatey cookie yet! Serve at room temp for a delicious fudge filling or warmed up for a flow of hot chocolate lava! 


The Lava Cake cookie is all cake and all cookies with a homemade fudge filling and topped with powdered sugar. Warm it up for a hot fudge lava expansion or eat at room temperature for a thicker fudge-like experience.

Peanut Butter Fudge
Peanut Butter Fudge

A deep dark chocolate cookie with heavy cream and local chocolate chips mixed in. This combination creates a fudge-like texture and it is filled with a whole scoop of all-natural peanut butter that is made in Telford, PA.

Disclaimer: These amazing cookies are made with natural Peanut Butter, oils may separate in transit.

Oreos & Cream
Oreos & Cream

We put in about 4 to 5 Oreos per cookie by blending the Oreos super fine and then dumping a ton in each batch of our Oreos & Cream cookies. Finished off with an Oreo on top and then baked in the oven to perfection.

shipping details

Baked and shipped the same day. Hand made fresh every day in Lancaster, Pennsylvania using only the best ingredients we can find.

Express shipping is the only way we ship. We do this to keep the transit time to a minimum so you can enjoy your cookies for the maximum amount of time. We do not guarantee delivery dates so make sure you select a date that has some flexibility. For all shipping questions, please visit our Shipping Details Page.
Baked To Order • Ships The Same Day
Regular price
$68.94 USD
Regular price
Sale price
$68.94 USD

Only pay $17.23 today.
Split the total into 4 interest-free payments
by selecting AfterPay® at checkout.

Based on 944 reviews
78%
(741)
8%
(73)
6%
(54)
5%
(50)
3%
(26)
Some were great & some were so-so

I have ordered before & know they are meant to be gooey inside but some seemed a bit underdone. That's ok though because I'm still enjoying them by eating around the middle!!!

Loved it!!!!

I've tried a lot of shipped cookies, and this by far is the best tasting ones. They are soft and, way bigger than I thought they would be. I will be getting more as soon as possible.

OUTSTANDING 😊 oatmeal w raisin

This is THE BEST OATMEAL COOKIE I have ever ate ! Hands down!!!

Arrived nice and fresh and were very delicious

New Fav

I’ve tried several flavors of these cookies, and all of them are delicious! They arrive fresh every time. My new favorite is the oatmeal raisin.

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Marianne Lynch

Good cookies but just found out I'm diabetic. Can you make a few that are sugar free? I'll be the guinea pig to test them out. :)

S
The Cookie Club
Sara VanderPas
So good!

I like being able to choose different cookies every month with the membership. The cookies are very good and even better warmed up! I know they are on the more expensive side, but definitely worth it once in a while for a gift or a treat for yourself.

Excellent

All of them are excellent

Almost perfect

Love these cookies so much. All my cookies were good except the smores cookie. The marshmallow tasted too tart. Wasnt sure why. I told them. They said they didnt know either.

I was really looking forward to these cookies!

I ordered the choose my own box. And then doubled down on the 'they choose my box'. Reviews looked good and my husband will eat just about anything! I received the two boxes and the texture and taste are lackluster. We've tried six kinds so far and feel like all are a bust. Wouldn't have taken the time to leave negative feedback but received and request for the review.

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kathleen Gonano

Every cookie was delicious!

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Margaret Carley
Out of Stock Items

The cookies are great; however, the same cookies were out of stock for this order as the ones for my last order a couple months ago. I’d really like to try them, but they are still not available.

Army Soldiers Loved them!!!!

Ordered these for my son and his fellow soldiers based in Georgia as a treat and thank you for their service. They loved them and truly appreciate being remembered - Army Mom Jill

Unbelievable

Love these cookies! Will definitely be ordering again…yummy

Your cookies are delicious 😋

Not great

My cookies arrived later than I was told they would(5days later). I did not get any correspondence from the company until I called and said that my cookie order had been canceled. When they arrived, there was oil in most of the cookie bags. The cookies were pretty good but not great. I would have loved to taste them without the oil to give them a fair chance.

D
Choose Your Own Cookies
Donna M Taylor
Cookies

They were all dried out. Whenever I took a bite the whole cookie would crumble. Didn't expect that from $69 cookies

Exceptional cookies!

Super sized, super rich and yummy!

Delicious!!

These cookies are so delicious. I freeze them and then heat them in microwave. Add ice cream and you have a fantastic easy dessert. They are of course delicious right out of the bag, too. Treat yourself, family and friends.

J
Everyone’s Favorite
Janine Dubina
Cookie perfect and an excellent gift for someone with a sweet tooth.

The recipient loved, loved, loved the cookies but the gift card was excluded but NOT the price.

Love them

Yum!

You can't really call this a cookie. It's so much more! Besides being absolutely delicious, the company goes much further for their customers. The packaging is thoughtful and protective. They handle the freezer and the microwave equally beautifully. It's a good thing I don't live near their store or I would be broke all the time!

Fabulous cookies

Absolutely love these cookies I had been dying to try them and I certainly was not disappointed- definitely a customer for life so delicious!

Remarkable!

My second purchase, and my second "WOW"! You folks really offer a wonderful product...the only potential hiccup was the shipping aspect. My first order was received with some of the dozen in pieces (but still within their individual bags), so was sceptical of the second order. No worries, as this order arrived unharmed! Bottom line is...these are remarkably good cookies, that are worth the dollar!

They are all very delicious. Froze some and then microwaved them. Taste just as good as the fresh.