Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie

Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide

Description

Introducing the delightful Oatmeal Creme Pie—a nostalgic treat with a local, homemade twist! Imagine sinking your teeth into a soft, chewy oatmeal cookie that transports you right back to the joys of childhood, but with a grown-up touch.

We blend hearty oats with a touch of warming spices to create a flavor that's both comforting and exhilarating. But the real star? Our delicious, housemade vanilla icing, filled inside of the dough.

Crafted with locally sourced ingredients, this cookie isn't just a snack; it's a trip down memory lane with a sprinkle of hometown pride. Perfect for anyone who's ever loved an oatmeal raisin cookie, or remembers the simple pleasure of a classic oatmeal cream pie. It's a classic that's only available for a limited time!


Allergens

Wheat, Dairy, Cornstarch, Eggs

Oatmeal Creme Pie Cookie Ingredients

Unbleached Enriched Wheat Flour, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Oats, Local Butter, Local Free-Range Eggs, Vanilla Extract, Cinnamon, Leavening (Aluminum Free Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Corn Starch) Himalayan Pink Salt, Filling (Butter, Powdered Sugar, Vanilla, Tapioca Syrup, Fluff, Heavy Cream)

Based on 1423 reviews
79%
(1119)
8%
(120)
7%
(95)
2%
(34)
4%
(56)
J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Joan McLaughlin
Amazing cookies!

Easy to place an order, received my cookies in perfect order.

We Just Keep On Buying

This is our fourth order and we couldn't be more satisfied with the cookies. The hardest part of our order is deciding what to order quantity-wise out of a dozen. There are just too many good choices to make. Already looking forward to our next order.

Omg…..these cookies are so yummy

Great cookies….soft, fresh, selection is so so good, delivery was fast, and I ate a dozen all by myself!!! My favs: snickerdoodle, chocolate lava and of course the season’s best - pumpkin. They are addicting!

Choose Cookies

I wish we could choose all the flavors.

1/2 dozen cookies!!!

They were all delicious as usual. My favorites are the: white chocolate macadamia nut and the chocolate with oreos and m&m's!!!!! Thank you

They are good but expensive!!

Around $10 a cookie!! Really! They are good but not $70 for half dozen!! Ouch!!!!

These cookies are the best!

My favorite cookie is crunchy on the outside, soft in the middle and these are the bomb! Perfect consistency! I can't even pick a favorite as they are all good! I will definitely reorder to try all flavors!

Mm good

Cookies are awesome. The pumpkin spice was like eating cake, it was delicious. Looking forward to more 😋

Best cookies ever

Ordered a dozen of our favorites!!
Most went in the freezer ...... they freeze extremely well!!! This way we enjoy for the next several weeks.

Great cookies, even better company

I can't say enough good things about this company. The cookies are superb, interesting and taste great- Wonderful gifts
What really separates this company is the extraordinary customer service- in an age when quality customer service is a challenge for many companies, Taylor Chip stands out above the rest in making sure that you are valued as a customer, and the product is excellent.

E
Choose Your Own Cookies
Elizabeth Pendleton
Delicious!!

These cookies are so yum. They are best a little warm to me but either way. So good

E
Choose Your Own Cookies
Eftihia Montano
LIKED ALL - EXCEPT ONE

I LOVE ALL THEIR COOKIES. I PICK MY OWN, I CANT HAVE NUTS. EVERYONE I HAVE CHOSEN HAS BEEN GREAT. I ONE I DID NOT LIKE WAS THE SNICKERDOODLE.

Amazing

Amazing

very good , looked bigger in your ad

D
Choose Your Own Cookies
Debra Pastuszak
Delectable Taste

Every bite is a mouth watering experience. Chocolate Lava outstanding!

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
Lauren Angotti
Delicious!

Tried several flavors and all were amazing! The Oatmeal cream were my favorite. These were the
Best cookies I’ve ever purchased!

10/10

Cookie review

Loved the cookies!

Quite good

They surpassed my expectations. Very tasty and lived up to the descriptions. One star deducted for the restrictions of choice due to cookies only permitted on cookie plan. Forcing prepayment for 6 or 12 months is not a way to generate long-term customer support.

Cookies are the best. I’ve tried others but Taylor is my choice

Delicious cookies

They never disappoint! So good!!!

PBJ

Great subtle taste with the right amount of sweetness.

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Mike Vercautren

The cookies were very very good! Only reason for not 5 stars is there were a few that were too crispy/crunchy already. I know it is hard to ship cookies and not make this happen since my wife has been baking and shipping cookies for 30 years. We started ordering cookies on line for about 3 years now to test others, and overall yours have been one of the best. Great luck with your company. Mike

Receiver of Gift Very Happy

Gave as a thank you gift and comment was, 'best cookies I've ever had!' Shipping was very timely. Thank you.