Collection: Cookies for Super Bowl

When game day excitement kicks in, Cookies for Super Bowl from Taylor Chip bring the perfect blend of sweetness and fun, making every party or gathering more memorable with delicious, handcrafted treats for fans to enjoy.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$

58 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

58 of 58 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$

58 products

Based on 1564 reviews
79%
(1235)
8%
(129)
7%
(102)
2%
(36)
4%
(62)
Best Cookies on the market

Have had them in Hershey when visiting my son and just ordered to have them shipped. Will make you never have Crumble again. Cinnamon Roll is my favorite but all of the Peanut butter ones are awesome. Loved the snickerdoodle and Oreo also. The peanut butter and jelly was surprising good also. Quick shipping over the holiday.

Great as always

Love these cookies. I may need to go to rehab :-)

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kendall Gaddis

Great cookies!!

I have been wanting to try Taylor Chip cookies for over a year after constantly seeing them pop up on social media, so I finally ordered a dozen to share with my family for our holiday get-together. I ordered a dozen cookies in 6 different flavors, and the only "flavor" we could taste was the overwhelming taste of sugar. We cut the cookies in 4s on the day of so they stayed wrapped and fresh until just before we ate them, and all 7 of us agreed that they were lacking in flavor and not worth the money or the calories. I was craving mint chocolate all season and was really looking forward to trying the chocolate peppermint cookie but it was just an sugar and didn't taste much different to the snickerdoodle or the regular chocolate chip and so on. I'm really disappointed because I really wanted to like them and feel like it was a waste of money, and I feel like I let my family down by bringing a dessert people didn't really enjoy.

Fantastic Cookies

Choose your own cookies were great. They were all delicious. Favorites were the chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin. Would definitely order again. Everyone agreed they were fabulous and stored well. Loved them!

Good but not great!

Some of the selection were great others were so so.

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Judith E Malavasi
Delicious Cookies

I bought these for a Christmas gift and also got to enjoy. We had to try each flavor that I purchased. What a delicious, soft and fantastic cookie. We had them in the refrigerator and would reheat in microwave for 30 seconds and let it sit before eating. They are so worth the price. Favorite was the Chocolate Chip, Lava, Brownie/Chocolate and Cookies and Cream was the best we ever had. Birthday one was on the sugary side.

Better option than Crumbl

These cookies are good. I do have to say they are pretty sweet and it would be nice if they had half the amount of sugar. I would much rather get Taylor Chip over Crumbl any given day!

I am in love

love the cookies they are such a treat

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Carolyn Stevenson
My Choice

Loved the variety that we could choose from

Best. Cookies. Ever.

Just order them you know you want to! Worth the money and supporting a great company that has a sweet beginning. Cinnamon bun, smores, and oatmeal cream pie are the best! Holiday flavors toasted coconut and white chocolate cranberry 🤌

Wonderful Christmas dessert

All the cookies were delicious and everyone loved them. The favorite was probably oatmeal raisin but they were all wonderful.

Best Cookies EVER!

If it's not Taylor Chip, it's not the best cookies your money can buy. Fast shipping, excellent service and hands down BEST cookies on the planet. I challenge you to find a better cookie anywhere on the planet.

Love It !

I love being able to choose the cookies !

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Christine Kelsey
Choose your own package-delivery

Delicious, decadent cookies. Delivered on time. The whole experience was excellent.
Thank you!

N
Choose Your Own Cookies
Nikole Rotunda
Down home treats that never disappoint!

These are the BEST cookies! We have our favorite flavors but never regret trying new ones. These were a huge hit as surprise Christmas gifts too!

Excellent quality and DELICIOUS

Received my order and the family went wild! I had to hide the box and dole out the cookies!

GF Not the Best

We got the GF cookies as a gift and there were mixed reviews. We were told that the pumpkin cookies were inedible but the chocolate ones were fine. We also couldn't figure out how to add a gift note to the order - doesn't affect the review score, but would be a nice option for future orders.

The cookies are delicious, warmed up made them even better!

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Catherine McKeithen
Excellent!!

Delicious cookies were a huge hit with my cookie loving family!

Xmas gift

Loved them! High quality product. Enjoyed by friends and family.

Addictive

These are amazing love the new holiday cookies.

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Krista Scanlan

They came quickly and were delicious! It was my first time ordering and the discount with free shipping was the push I needed to try them! Everyone enjoyed them at the holidays!

A
Choose Your Own Cookies
Alyssa Kastens
Delicious!

The cookies are delicious! And they freeze well.

Loved everything! Will order again! Great gift!

  • Kick off your Super Bowl party with cookies that are a touchdown hit! Whether you opt for classic sugar cookies cut into fun, thematic shapes like footballs and trophies or go for bold flavors like Double Chocolate Delight, these treats are sure to impress. Use royal icing to decorate with team colors and create designs that capture the game day spirit. Arrange these eye-catching cookies on themed platters or in tiered trays for a stunning display. Don't forget to package them creatively for memorable party favors. Uncover more about how to make your Super Bowl cookies the center of attention.

    Types of Super Bowl Cookies

    When planning your Super Bowl party, you'll want to contemplate a variety of cookie options to delight your guests. Start with classic sugar cookies, and then add themed football and trophy designs to get everyone in the spirit. Don't forget to mix in some chocolate and unique flavor variations for an unexpected twist.

    Classic Sugar Cookies

    Classic sugar cookies often make the perfect addition to any Super Bowl gathering, offering a sweet and versatile treat that's loved by many. To create these delightful cookies, start with a classic sugar cookies recipe that calls for all-purpose flour, butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla extract. Roll out the dough and use cookie cutters to shape the cookies into fun designs. Place them on a baking sheet and bake until they're golden.

    Once cooled, it's time to decorate. Prepare a royal icing recipe, which typically includes powdered sugar, egg whites, and lemon juice. Use this icing to add colorful designs and personalize each cookie. These classic sugar cookies are sure to be a hit, adding a touch of sweetness to your Super Bowl party spread.

    Themed Football and Trophy Cookies

    How can you raise your Super Bowl party treats beyond the ordinary? Create themed football and trophy cookies that capture the spirit of the game. Start with football cookie cutters to shape your dough into perfect football shapes. Your guests will love the adorable football cookies, especially when they see each cookie with laces marked across the top. This simple detail adds authenticity and charm to your treats. If you're a fan of chocolate chip cookies, try incorporating them into your football designs. You can press chocolate chips into the dough or use them to outline the laces. By adding these themed cookies to your party spread, you'll impress your guests and score big on creativity and taste.

    Chocolate and Unique Flavor Variations

    As the Super Bowl kicks off, it's the perfect time to raise your cookie game with chocolate and unique flavor variations. Imagine biting into a classic chocolate chip cookie, its gooey center melting in your mouth. Now, envision enhancing this experience with a few creative twists. Here's how:

    1. Double Chocolate Delight: Add baking cocoa to your dough for a rich, indulgent treat. Sprinkle in mini chocolate chips for extra texture and taste.

    2. Spicy Chocolate Kick: Introduce a pinch of cayenne pepper or cinnamon to your mix, offering a surprising zing that pairs well with chocolate.

    3. Nutty Madness: Mix in chopped pecans or almonds for a crunchy, nutty surprise.

    These unique flavor variations will transform your cookies into an exciting game day activity.

    Decorating Techniques for Super Bowl Cookies

    Get ready to transform your cookies into showstoppers by mastering royal icing basics. Use team colors to add that extra flair and let your creativity shine with unique designs. You'll impress every guest with cookies that taste as good as they look.

    Royal Icing Basics

    When it comes to decorating Super Bowl cookies, mastering royal icing is essential for creating eye-catching designs. Start by preparing a smooth white icing as your base. It provides a clean slate for your creativity to shine. To transform plain cookies into miniature masterpieces, consider these steps:

    1. Outline and Flood: Use cookie icing to outline your cookie's adorable football shape, then fill it in to create a seamless surface.
    2. Detailing: Once your base has set, carefully pipe laces using a slightly thicker icing consistency. This adds realistic football laces that pop.
    3. Finishing Touches: Add accents like stripes or borders to enhance your design and make each cookie truly unique.

    Team Colors and Creative Designs

    With Super Bowl cookies, embracing team colors and creative designs guarantees your treats stand out at any viewing party. Start by using a football-shaped cookie cutter to create the classic sports theme. Use brown food coloring in your icing to mimic the authentic look of a football. Pipe on white chocolate laces for that realistic touch. These cookies for game day will surely impress your guests.

    For an extra pop of team spirit, add color-coordinated candies that match your favorite team's colors. Arrange them creatively on each cookie to enhance the design. This attention to detail not only shows your dedication but also adds a delicious, festive flair. With these techniques, your cookies will be the MVP of any Super Bowl gathering.

    Super Bowl Cookie Recipes and Instructions

    You're ready to whip up some game-day treats, so let's start with a simple sugar cookie recipe and a few baking tips to guarantee they're perfect. Once you've got those cookies baked and cooled, you can prepare a royal icing that's easy to apply and adds a professional touch. We'll walk you through a step-by-step decorating guide that'll make your cookies the MVP of any Super Bowl party.

    Sugar Cookie Recipe and Baking Tips

    As you gear up for the Super Bowl, there's no better time to bake a batch of sugar cookies that not only taste delicious but also capture the festive spirit of the event. Start by preheating your oven and gathering ingredients. Mix 1 tsp vanilla extract with sugar, butter, and eggs until smooth. In a separate bowl, combine flour and baking powder. Gradually mix the dry and wet ingredients. Roll out the dough and cut into fun shapes. Place them on cookie sheets.

    While baking, envision this:

    1. Golden cookies emerging from the oven.
    2. Fragrant vanilla wafting through your kitchen.
    3. Cooling cookies on wire racks, ready to be decorated.

    Once done, let them cool completely before serving or storing. Enjoy!

    Royal Icing Recipe and Application

    Transform your Super Bowl sugar cookies into a festive treat with a perfect batch of royal icing. Start by mixing powdered sugar, meringue powder, and water until smooth. For football-themed cookies with icing, divide the icing into separate bowls. Add drops of gel food coloring to each, creating vibrant team colors. Use cookie sticks for easy handling as you dip or pipe the icing onto your cookies. To achieve clean, defined lines, adjust the consistency by adding a little more water or sugar. Once the base coat dries, use white icing to draw the iconic white laces on football-shaped cookies. This royal icing not only adds flavor but also creates a smooth, professional finish to delight your Super Bowl guests.

    Step-By-Step Decorating Guide

    Creating festive Super Bowl cookies involves a series of simple steps to bring your football-themed treats to life. Start with your favorite chocolate chip cookie dough to create a delightful base. Once baked, it's time to transform these sweet treats into cute football-shaped cookies. Begin by cutting the cookies into football shapes using a cookie cutter. Now, let's decorate:

    1. Outline and Fill: Use royal icing to outline and fill the football cookies. Opt for brown icing to mimic a football's leather.

    2. Add Details: With white icing, draw the laces and stitching details, bringing authenticity to your treats.

    3. Assemble Platters: Arrange your decorated cookies on cookie platters, mixing with other themed snacks for a game-day presentation.

    Enjoy your delicious football cookies!

    Presentation and Packaging Ideas

    Think about how you can make your Super Bowl cookies stand out with creative presentation and packaging. Arrange them on themed platters, perhaps with team colors or football decorations, to bring a festive touch to your spread. For a thoughtful twist, consider using decorative bags or boxes for party favors or gifts.

    Cookie Platters and Themed Decorations

    A few well-chosen presentation ideas can transform your Super Bowl cookie platter into a show-stopping centerpiece. As a cookie connoisseur, you'll want to impress your guests with a cookie tray that showcases your dozen cookies as delicious treats perfect for game day. Here are three creative ways to enhance your presentation:

    1. Themed Platter Arrangement: Arrange your cookies in the shape of a football or team logo using colored icing and edible decorations. It'll create a fun, eye-catching display.

    2. Color-Coordinated Decorations: Use team colors in napkins, plates, and ribbons to tie the theme together, making your platter a visual treat.

    3. Tiered Trays: Present your cookies on tiered trays for added dimension and elegance, allowing each delicious treat to shine.

    Party Favors and Gifting Options

    While your cookie platter captures everyone's attention during the game, consider extending the festive spirit beyond the table with thoughtful party favors and gifting options. Start by gifting small batches of cookie dough in airtight containers, allowing your guests the joy of baking fresh cookies at home. This guarantees they get to experience the aroma and taste of freshly baked cookies, making them irresistible.

    Alternatively, package a selection of your baked cookies in decorative boxes or bags. Include a mix of favorites like chocolate chip cookie bars and other varieties to delight your guests. Ascertain each package is sealed to maintain freshness and flavor. These thoughtful gestures not only extend the celebration but also leave your guests with sweet memories of your Super Bowl party.

    You've got everything you need to create the perfect Super Bowl cookies. From exploring different types and mastering decorating techniques to following detailed recipes, you're all set to impress your guests. Don't forget to present and package them creatively for that extra wow factor. Enjoy the game and the delicious treats you've prepared. Remember, with a little effort and creativity, your Super Bowl cookies will be the highlight of the party. Get ready to score big!