Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide

Single Cookie

Yellow Soft Sugar Cookie

Say hello to sunshine in cookie form. Our Yellow Soft Sugar Cookie brings the brightness with a buttery, chewy vanilla cookie topped in a smooth, golden yellow frosting made from all-natural dyes. This one’s... read more

allergens

Wheat, Dairy, Cornstarch, Eggs

ingredients

Cookie: Unbleached Enriched Wheat Flour, Sugar, Local Free-Range Eggs, Vanilla Extract, butter Frosting: powdered sugar, vanilla, heavy cream, butter, tapioca syrup and turmeric

Description

Say hello to sunshine in cookie form. Our Yellow Soft Sugar Cookie brings the brightness with a buttery, chewy vanilla cookie topped in a smooth, golden yellow frosting made from all-natural dyes. This one’s giving Easter egg hunts, tulips in bloom, and warm spring vibes in every bite. Simple, sweet, and made to make you smile. Limited time only—don’t let it slip away!

Based on 1890 reviews
77%
(1457)
8%
(156)
7%
(128)
3%
(51)
5%
(98)
S
Choose Your Own Cookies
Shannon Silvia
USPS Trouble

I would like to commend the customer service that Taylor Chip provides to its customers. I couldn't have had a better outcome from a USPS mistake. My sister moved into a new apartment and had not listed as a resident with the post office before I sent her a "We miss you already" cookie package. The USPS "returned to sender-Addressee unknown." I contacted Taylor Chip who graciously offered a discount to reship another package once my sister got things squared away with the post office. I appreciate the help that was offered and my sister greatly appreciated the cookies she finally received. She reported that the cookies were so soft and doey and especially good if heated for a little in the microwave.

Loved as always

Great tasting cookies

Outstanding cookies!

These are phenomenal cookies! They are delicious and huge! It’s hard for me to eat a whole cookie!

Absolutely delicious!

The assortment of cookies we received from you is delicious and we’re eating them now, it really is almost impossible to stop at home! We could’ve gone to cancel out and had them on hand 🖐️ and have some thing to do around lunchtime if they I

Best cookies ever!

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
Lesline Amedee-Jones
Deeeeelicious!

I put it in the frig and reheat in micro. They are so good. They were too large for one person, so I break them into 2 and share with my husband.

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jacquelyn Goodrich
COOKIES!

Everything tasted so yummy. Did freeze some for later.

Ok, super sweet

Was really excited to try because they said they make their own cookies with fine ingredients. No ingredients were listed, that would be a nice change.

Phenomenal

The best cookies EVER!

Choose your own

Some cookies were not as fresh as those in the past.

They looked great and are delicious!

Cookies!!!!!

These are so good. I ordered them as a birthday gift to me!! My husband and I usually split one cookie except for the Lava and s’mores.

Amazing cookies all of the flavors I picked were outstanding and very good quality.

R
Choose Your Own Cookies
Rebecca Caldwell
Another great batch of comfort

Repeat customer and haven't found a bad cookie yet. Enjoyed every single one and will come back again the next time I need some comfort cookies. Thank you!

These are amazing

These cookies are amazing. I could have eaten the entire box.

Never run out of Doug’s Fluffernutter !!!

The mint cookies were slightly dry, even after slightly heating. LOVE LOVE LOVE Dougs Fluffernutter though 😊

Not bad, but...

The missus and I enjoyed your cookies. We've had them for about two weeks (no refrigeration) and they're still chewy and yummy. She loved the double chocolate, and I liked the cookies & cream. That said, we did have a few issues: first, even with a significant discount, it still cost nearly $5 per cookie (which is not completely outrageous, but it is still pretty hefty); second, your distance from us is a problem -- ordering a dozen cookies is a lot for two, and while we can give them away to friends, what? are you crazy?! Third, and this is no slight to your cookie-making prowess, my wife's homemade chocolate chip cookies are the best gol-durn cookies I've ever eaten, and it's not even close! Unfortunately, she only makes them a couple times a year (no matter how much I beg). All this to say, we do like your cookies, but it'll probably only be a once-a-year thing for us, if that.

March Treats

Everyone love the cookies; especially the chocolate lava ones!

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kyrsten Hammar
All taste the same

Although they all have their uniqueness and they were tasty I just felt like I was eating the same cookie over and over… I also didn’t like how they seemed a bit raw even after heating it up. A suggestion I would have is to include instructions on how to best eat them if ordering online, they just weren’t worth all the hype for me but I feel like getting them in person would be a different experience.

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Carolyn Jenkins

As always love your cookies. But those maple pecan was so YUMMY. Maple is one of my favorite flavors. Keep them in your selection. Just gave a box to a friend for her birthday loved is hooked.

Everybody just loves them!

State of the art in the cookie world

There's Taylor Chip and there's everybody else... honestly Taylor chip is the only serious choice ! Drop mic

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jonathan Philbrick
Just ok

That’s it. Just ok. Super super sweet.

k
Choose Your Own Cookies
kristen Becker
Wonderful cookies

Wonderful cookies ! Top notch ingredients and delicious flavor