Specialty Cookies

We've really outdone ourselves with our Taylor Chip Specialty Cookies Category! Each cookie, weighing at least 5.5oz, promises a delightful, substantial treat. Let's not forget our showstoppers, like the campfire-inspired S'mores Cookies, the brilliant Brookie Cookies where brownie meets cookie, or the intriguing Lemon Lavender Cookies—each one a fresh, handcrafted masterpiece. We're also mindful of dietary needs, offering gluten-free, nut-free, and vegan options. Curious about what makes our Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookies a sweet and salty marvel, or how we pack every Rocky Road Cookie with marshmallows and nuts? There's a whole world of flavors waiting just around the corner.

Customers rate us 4.6/5 based on 1464 reviews.

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $92.94 Reset
$
$
Clear all

24 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

24 of 24 products

Availability
Clear
Price

The highest price is $92.94

$
$
Clear all

24 products

Specialty Cookies
expand_more
  • Cookie Bundles
  • Types of Cookies
  • Online Cookie Order
  • Holiday Cookies
  • Cookie Cakes
  • Cookie Delivery
  • Gluten Free Cookies
  • Vegan Cookies
  • Cookies for Different Occasions
    • Choose Your Own Cookies
      Choose Your Own Cookies
      Customize your selection from all flavors.
      From $49.97 USD
      From $49.97 USD
      Choose Your Own Cookies
      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      Select Cookies
    • Everyone’s Favorite Cookie Bundle
      Everyone’s Favorite Cookie Bundle
      Flavor Details
      From $49.97 USD
      From $49.97 USD
      Size

      We’ve taken the guess work out of your selection process and picked out the most consistently top selling cookies and put them in this assortment we appropriately call “Everyone’s Favorite”.

      Our Delightfully Perfect cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

      Flavors

      • S’mores
      • Chocolate Chip
      • Brookie
      • Salted Caramel Pretzel
      • Snickerdoodle
      • Oreos & Cream


      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    • The Most Chocolatey Cookie Bundle
      The Most Chocolatey Cookie Bundle
      Flavor Details
      From $49.97 USD
      From $49.97 USD
      Size

      If you LOVE chocolate and aren’t afraid of some cookies with nuts in them then this is the bundle for you! We’ve put together the best chocolate lover’s assortment you are sure to be head over heels for.

      Our Delightfully Perfect cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

      Flavors:

      • Double Chocolate Brownie
      • Chocolate Chip
      • Brookie
      • Lava Cake
      • Peanut Butter Fudge
      • Oreos & Cream

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    • Gluten-Friendly Cookie Bundle
      Gluten-Friendly Cookie Bundle
      Flavor Details
      From $55.95 USD
      From $55.95 USD
      Size

      Our Free from gluten cookies are made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes. Based on the cookie that started it all, it took the perfect combination of specialty flours and the right taste before we felt good about adding any gluten free cookies to the lineup and are proud to say we couldn’t be happier with it.

      Our Delightfully Perfect gluten-free cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

      Flavors:

      • Chocolate Chip
      • Loaded Peanut Butter
      • Double Chocolate Brownie
      • Brookie

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    • Vegan-Friendly Cookie Bundle
      Vegan-Friendly Cookie Bundle
      Flavor Details
      From $55.95 USD
      From $55.95 USD
      Size

      Our 100% vegan cookies are so good, you wouldn’t even know they were vegan and we do all of this without that horrible processed oils & fats. They are made with mostly certified organic ingredients and non-GMO. Sometimes we non-vegan at TC even prefer them over the regular ones – They’re THAT GOOD!

      Our Delightfully Perfect vegan cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

      Flavors:

      • Vegan Sugar
      • Vegan Brookie
      • Vegan Double Chocolate Brownie
      • Vegan Chocolate Chip
      • Vegan Loaded Peanut Butter
      • Vegan Oreos & Cream

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    • Everything Nutty Cookie Bundle
      Everything Nutty Cookie Bundle
      Flavor Details
      From $49.97 USD
      From $49.97 USD
      Size

      Truly something to go nuts over, our “Everything Nutty” assortment is exactly what a nut lover like yourself would ask for out of your cookies and you can feel confident in the ingredients they are made with. All peanut butter cookies are made with all natural 100% American peanuts that have no sugar, or oils added.

      Our Delightfully Perfect cookies are at least 5.5oz each and made by hand fresh every day.

      Flavors:

      • Peanut Butter & Jelly
      • Loaded Peanut Butter
      • White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
      • Peanut Butter Fudge
      • PB Explosion
      • PB Nutella (filled)


      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie
      Chocolate Chip Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When you’re searching for the best chocolate chip cookie ever, our bakers use a perfected recipe that combines rich, creamy butter, locally sourced vanilla, and an abundance of high-quality chocolate chips, making certain that each cookie has a perfectly crisp exterior, a soft and chewy center, and a balanced sweetness that can provide cookie lovers with a truly unforgettable experience.

      The cookie that started it all! Inspired by a cookie that was made with vegetable shortening, the goal was to create a cookie that had that same density and thickness but with simple, natural, ingredients. It took us over a year, but we made it even better. Most would say, it’s the best cookie they ever had.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Brookie Cookie
      Brookie Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When you can’t decide between a cookie and a brownie, our bakers create the Brookie by combining the best of both worlds—a soft, chocolate chip cookie dough layered over a rich, fudgy brownie base—making certain that each bite is a perfect harmony of crisp cookie edges and gooey brownie decadence that can provide dessert enthusiasts with the ultimate treat experience.

      The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Birthday Cake Cookie
      Birthday Cake Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When you want to celebrate with a treat that captures the essence of a party in every bite, our bakers craft the *Birthday Cake Cookie* using creamy vanilla, colorful sprinkles, and white chocolate chips, making certain that each cookie is packed with sweet, festive flavors that can provide cookie enthusiasts with a fun and nostalgic experience reminiscent of classic birthday celebrations.

      We wouldn’t want to celebrate our 5 year anniversary any other way then by releasing BIRTHDAY CAKE! A sweet vanilla cookie, packed full with colorful sprinkles AND filled with our house-made vanilla Icing. This cookie has an explosion of cake batter flavor and is better than the funfetti cake we all adored as kids! We have a feeling it will quickly become a Taylor Chip Classic :)

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Cinnamon Bun Cookie
      Cinnamon Bun Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When you’re craving the comforting flavors of a classic cinnamon roll in a portable, cookie form, our bakers craft the Cinnamon Bun Cookie using a blend of rich cinnamon, brown sugar, and vanilla, making certain that each bite is soft, buttery, and swirled with a sweet cinnamon filling that can provide dessert lovers with a decadent and nostalgic experience.

      Ever wondered what would happen if we slapped a cinnamon bun into a Taylor Chip cookie? We took everything you know and love about the traditional moist, sweet, sticky pastry and elevated it with our signature bourbon vanilla glaze!

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookie
      Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When you’re craving the perfect mix of sweet, salty, and crunchy, our bakers craft the Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookie using chewy caramel, crunchy pretzel pieces, and a sprinkle of sea salt, making certain that each bite offers a delightful balance of textures and flavors that can provide cookie lovers with a satisfying and unique treat experience.

      One of our most beloved offerings, this cookie has a bold, rich flavor like no other. Brought on by our simple, 3 ingredient, corn syrup free, house made caramel sauce and locally sourced, fresh made Hammond’s Pretzels from Lancaster City.

      Disclaimer: Due to Caramel, cookie will arrive very messy within its individual package.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie
      Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      When a single dose of chocolate just isn’t enough, our bakers craft the Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie using premium cocoa and an extra helping of rich chocolate chips, making certain that each bite is a dense, fudgy delight packed with layers of deep chocolate flavor that can provide dessert enthusiasts with an intensely satisfying experience.

      The perfect blend of cookie and brownie. We put in a double portion of rich, intense dutch processed cocoa and combine that with a copious amount of local chocolate from Lititz, Pennsylvania.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Chocolate Chip Biscuit Cookie
      Chocolate Chip Biscuit Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      50% less sugar than our normal cookies and a great option for breakfast! Our biscuit is the perfect blend of cookie biscuit and scone. This is a completely new experience.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Gluten-Friendly Brookie Cookie
      Gluten-Friendly Brookie Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $6.50 USD
      $6.50 USD
      Title

      Our Free From Gluten Brookie cookie is made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes.The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cookie
      Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      A twist of salty and sweet… we had this classic in mind for our cookie friends! Crunchy Hammond’s Pretzels mixed with heaps of smooth Wilbur Chocolate Semi-Sweets, this cookie has all the right flavors and textures. The sprinkle of sea salt and drizzle of house made chocolate syrup make this cookie a delight! We like to call this one “The Perfect After Dinner Snack” as it hits all the right cravings 🙂

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    • High 5 Cookie
      High 5 Cookie
      Flavor Details
      $5.75 USD
      $5.75 USD
      Title

      Inspired by a popular candy bar (Take 5), we like to say it’s one heck of a cookie!! Layered with pretzels, chocolate, peanut butter and lathered with caramel to top.. it’s every candy lovers dream 😍🙌 One big, chunky bite and you’ll loose all of your self control 🤤 Available for a limited time at our Hershey location only!

      Cookie Club Exclusive. Join now!
      View Cookie
    Customers rate us 4.6/5 based on 1464 reviews.
    Based on 1464 reviews
    79%
    (1150)
    8%
    (122)
    7%
    (98)
    2%
    (36)
    4%
    (58)
    H
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Henry Rodriguez
    Scrumptious Cookies

    Really moist delicious cookies Delivery of cookies was very fast Will order again!

    T
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    TIMOTHY BALMER
    Awesome

    I love these cookies! I like to use 20 secs microwave heating, melts the insides.....

    W
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    William Wenner
    They are great

    They are great

    T
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Tina Uebler

    They are awesome.

    K
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Kathleen Wade
    Just yum!

    The cookies are big enough to share! And sooooo delicious. You’ve knocked them out of the park, Taylor Chip! Thank you for this delicious experience!

    User picture
    K
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Kevin Jordan

    The best cookies in my opinion

    S
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Shelly Driscoll
    The best EVER!

    Sent these as a belated birthday present to my son-in-law and he was absolutely over the moon and barely shared them with his wife, our daughter! Highly recommend Taylor chip!

    H
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Homer Alafa, Jr.
    Delicious!!!

    All the cookies ordered were delicious!!! Highly recommend!!!

    C
    Gluten-Friendly Cookie Bundle
    Cindy Pearson
    Cookies

    This cookie bundle was my first purchase and they did not dissapoint. All of the cookies in the bundle were good. I would definitely purchase again.

    S
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Sarah Angelim
    Amazing!!!

    I’ve been debating whether to get these cookies for a while cause it keeps showing up on my feed. Finally got them shipped, they’re AMAZING. Hands down the best cookies I’ve ever had. I’m so glad door dash delivers them in Philly center city now. I wish they’d have more flavors available for Philly, like S’mores!

    R
    Everyone’s Favorite Cookie Bundle
    Robert Schlossberg
    Cookie was ok

    Cookie at best was ok.

    K
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Karen Ketelaar
    Cookie club

    Loved all the cookies but the sugar cookie wasn’t cooked all the way and I had to throw it away. I’ve ordered this cookie before so I’m aware on how it looks when it’s not raw.

    P
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Pamela Heiberg
    Fast service

    Very fast service & great cookies!!!!

    K
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Kevin Hughes

    First time trying them… I enjoyed them…. I have nothing bad to say about them only that some of my family did not like them as much because it was to rich and thick in the middle… keep up the good work!

    M
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Melba Barnes

    I Bought a dozen for my family to try out for the holidays.....needless to say, they didn't last long in our house...

    E
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Ed Mahoney

    The cookies were good except the one I ordered the most of the Lava was way too sweet.
    My favorite was the white chocolate.

    P
    Custom Dozen
    Paul Connelley
    Cookies Purchase

    Excellent service and turn around! The cookies taste great!

    D
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Demond Wilson
    Delicious

    They are very good quality and very tasty. I haven’t had all the flavors yet but I’m excited to. I will be re ordering

    D
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Douglas Steffan
    Very tasty treat

    You can taste the quality in the ingredients and final product. 😋

    J
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Jean Smith

    Taylor Chip cookies are the best!!!

    D
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    DaMetrius Savage
    Cookie Delicious

    These cookies were excellent for my first try!! Will be ordering again in near future!!! Much love!!!

    J
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Jim Kay
    Amazing!

    Cookies are great, but when you put them in the oven to heat them up, it takes them to the next level!

    J
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Joseph Maniscalco
    Delish

    The cookies came well packaged and were delicious. A bit pricey but definitely a very good cookie

    W
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    William McCarthy
    Awesome!!

    The treat that is better than you imagined!

    F
    Choose Your Own Cookies
    Frank Angelino

    Great cookies

    • The Specials

      Indulge in the gooey S'mores Cookies, the decadent Brookie Cookies, or the unique Lemon Lavender Cookies. Each offers a distinct flavor adventure. Don't forget the playful Birthday Cake Cookies, perfect for any celebration. Trust us, we've got your cravings covered with these specially curated selections!

      Our Delightfully Perfect Cookies

      Our Delightfully Perfect cookies, each weighing at least 5.5oz, are crafted by hand daily to guarantee peak freshness and irresistible taste. They're not just cookies; they're a blend of quality, creativity, and care, designed to satisfy every cookie connoisseur.

      • S'mores Cookies: A campfire classic, reimagined.
      • Brookie Cookies: Brownie meets cookie in this delightful fusion.
      • Salted Caramel Pretzel Cookies: Sweet and salty perfection.
      • Rocky Road Cookies: Loaded with marshmallows and nuts.
      • Lemon Lavender Cookies: A invigorating twist with a floral hint.

      Handmade Fresh Daily

      Every day, we handcraft our cookies to guarantee they're fresh and full of flavor when they reach your table. From the gooey S'mores to the zesty Lemon Lavender, each cookie is a masterpiece of taste. We're passionate about delivering the best—ensuring every bite is a delightful experience. So, enjoy knowing each treat was made with care, just for you!

      Cookie Size

      While discussing our allergen practices, it's also important to note that each of our Delightfully Perfect cookies weighs at least 5.5oz. We're proud that our cookies are substantially sized, ensuring a satisfying treat with every bite. This heft reflects our commitment to quality and indulgence. We believe bigger is better when it comes to flavor and satisfaction in every delicious, handcrafted batch.

      Dietary Information

      We recognize the importance of accommodating various dietary needs and offer nut-free, gluten-free, vegan, and dairy-free options among our cookies. Here's what we've got:

      • Nut-free delights for allergy concerns
      • Gluten-free treats for sensitive tummies
      • Vegan cookies for plant-based diets
      • Dairy-free varieties for lactose intolerant folks
      • No artificial flavors or preservatives in our dietary options

      We're here to satisfy everyone's cookie cravings!

      Freshness and Quality

      Ensuring every cookie meets our high standards, Taylor Chip bakes with only the freshest, quality ingredients. We're committed to excellence, choosing locally sourced items whenever possible to guarantee that every bite delivers exceptional taste and quality. Our dedication to freshness transforms simple treats into memorable experiences, ensuring that each cookie is a perfect reflection of our craft and passion.

      Baked and Shipped Same Day

      To guarantee that you enjoy our cookies at their freshest, we bake and ship them on the same day. Here's how we maintain excellent quality:

      • Quality Ingredients: Only the finest components go into our batches.
      • Skilled Bakers: Our team's expertise guarantees perfect cookies every time.
      • Efficient Processing: Streamlined baking and packaging process.
      • Careful Handling: Ensures cookies aren't damaged.
      • Constant Monitoring: Freshness is our priority.

      Express Shipping

      After baking and packaging our cookies with care, we ship them swiftly through our express shipping service. This option guarantees you'll have our delicious treats in no time, whether you're craving a Brookie or a Lemon Lavender delight. We're committed to delivering freshness and speed, so you can enjoy your favorites fast, just as they're meant to be savored. Indulge without the wait!

      We're excited for you to try our Taylor Chip Spec