Nut Cookies

We've been diving into the delicious world of Taylor Chip Nut Cookies, where each bite offers a mix of crunchy nuts and sweet, chewy goodness. These baked cookies are...

The Most Chocolatey Cookie Bundle

If you LOVE chocolate and aren’t afraid of some cookies with nuts in them then...

Everything Nutty Cookie Bundle

Truly something to go nuts over, our “Everything Nutty” assortment is exactly what a nut...

Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie

When you’re craving a decadent treat that combines the creaminess of peanut butter with the...

Vegan-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

When you want a rich and satisfying treat packed with bold peanut butter flavor, our...

Maple Pecan Cookie

When you’re in the mood for a cookie that brings the warmth and richness of...

PB Explosion Cookie

This Hershey exclusive is an explosion of all the best peanut butter candies with every...

Kitchen Sink Cookie

Think everything bagel… but cookie form 🤤 Chalked full of crunchy delights like coconut, almonds, pretzels...

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

When you’re craving the nostalgic combination of peanut butter and sweet fruit jam, our bakers...

High 5 Cookie

Inspired by a popular candy bar (Take 5), we like to say it’s one heck...

Gluten-Friendly Loaded Peanut Butter Cookie

Our Free From Gluten Loaded Peanut Butter cookie is made with our own blend of...

Doug’s Fluffernutter Cookie

A Fluffernutter like cookie with a twist. The dough is mixed with 30lbs of an...

Brownie Peanut Butter Chip Cookie

When you're looking for the perfect combination of rich chocolate and creamy peanut butter, our...

White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie

When you’re in the mood for a luxurious treat that combines creamy white chocolate with...

Walnut Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Packed with fresh, chopped walnuts and Wilbur Brandywine Bittersweet Chocolate Chunks, this highly requested cookie...

Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie

Get ready for the ultimate cookie mashup with our Cookie Club exclusive flavor Peanut Butter...

Based on 1761 reviews
78%
(1380)
8%
(146)
7%
(117)
2%
(44)
4%
(75)
Great gift

I gave them as a gift and they were so nicely packaged and presented on top of being delicious.

Amazing cookies!!! They're so yummy

Great variety

My husband and I love the basic cookies.. choc chip, oatmeal raisin so start with them and try a few new ones with each order. Chocolate lava used to be my favorite now it’s s’mores. Cookies are shipped individually wrapped which is a big plus. They arrive fresh and delicious!

These are the best cookies!! I’ve ordered them more often than I like to admit. S’mores is my favorite flavor!

DELICIOUSNESS!!!!

I had seen these wonderful cookies on Facebook and decided to give them a try! And I’m so glad I did! I chose 12 of the pick your own package and each and everyone of them has been outstanding! You won’t be disappointed that’s for sure. They take cookies to a whole new level of YUMMINESS

G
Choose Your Own Cookies
Gregory Moulton
Shared Cookies

I had the pleasure of sharing my cookies with friends. Each and every one of my friends were amazed how good they were. They were especially taken by how soft and chewy they were.
To the owners and personnel working at Taylor, thank you for saying these would be the biggest and softest cookie I would ever have. The product you produce says that and more. I will definitely be ordering another dozen for my next event.

Thank you,

Gregory Moulton

G
Choose Your Own Cookies
Ginger Iconos-Watkins
Excellent

I sent two different orders to Son and Daughter out of town, they LOVED them! I’m going to send some to myself, can’t wait to try!! :)

Choose Your Own Cookies

I loved being able to choose the cookies for my order, as I was sending it as a gift to my daughter and son-in-law and knew what types of cookies they liked the best. Thanks for giving me the option to choose my own selection!

Ehhhh

When we opened the salted caramel cookie was not pretty. Kind of smashed and leaking out of top.
The PBJ was horrible. Kind of raw in the middle and wasn’t fond of the taste.
The other 4 were ok…not as good as the first time we had them. Maybe you guys were just too busy trying to fill Valentines orders.

The cookies were nice and soft, but a bit too rich for my liking. Delivery was on time and I appreciated that all cookies were wrapped in their own sealed wrapper and labeled clearly.

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
Lyndsey Andrews
Amazing batch!

Literally the best cookies I’ve ever eaten!! I’ll be back for more! I chose the dozen and couldn’t be happier. I’ve shared with many friends and they are obsessed!

R
Custom Dozen
Ronald Kozera
Warm it up

We found the cookies to be a nice treat. They are especially tasty when warmed up.

Gave this Cookie Bundle to our Grandsons and their wiife's, it was a HIT!!

Delicious!

This is our second time ordering cookies and we love every single bite! Obviously the cookies are best after a quick warm up in the oven. We usually keep them in the freezer and pull out one at a time to share after dinner. I love the ingredients and the creativity put into these recipes. SO GOOD!

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Justin Starkey
Best cookies!

The price is way too high for 12 cookies. But when I start eating them the taste is worth it!

L
Custom Dozen
Laura Parisi
Delish!

Nice assortment of cookies.🍪

All were delicious!

Sent these as a get well gift and they were received with open hands! Will definitely purchase again.

“Everyone’s Favorite Bundle” was my order.

I really enjoyed the cookies. The flavor was outstanding and the only reason I didn't give them five stars was the texture which I feel like could never be absolutely perfect reheating a cookie through the mail. My favorite was the lava surprisingly because I’m usually a traditional chocolate chip guy.

Good cookies! Limited flavor selection for gluten free cookies.

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Mary Louise Baker
Amazing!

Best cookies ever! I love how they’re pre packaged which allowed them to last longer. Just pop them in the microwave for 10 seconds and voila! Perfection!

Absolutely delicious!

I haven’t ordered in a year or two and they are just as wonderful as I remember, even better maybe! The shipping was quick and they arrived in wonderful condition considering the kinds I ordered. Thank you so much! I will definitely be recommending and ordering again!

Y
Choose Your Own Cookies
Yolonda Franklin

These cookies are so big and good. I warmed up like the directions said, and they didn't disappoint.

Simply delicious

I chose six different cookies for the first time and they were absolutely simply delicious. Major dessert.

P
Choose Your Own Cookies
Patricia Bechok
raw

Good flavors, but uncooked- raw in the middle, even after heating

P
Choose Your Own Cookies
PATRICIA REESER
TAKE THE CHALLENGE!

IT IS AN OPPORTUNITY NOT AFFORDED BY ALL COOKIE COMPANIES, YOU GET TO PICK ALL YOUR OWN CHOICES, THIS IS THE BEST WAY TO TRY AS MANY FLAVORS TEMPTING YOU UNTIL YOU HAVE NAROWED DOWN YOUR FAVORITES.