Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide

Description

When you’re craving the nostalgic combination of peanut butter and sweet fruit jam, our bakers craft the Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie using creamy peanut butter and a generous swirl of raspberry jam, making certain that each bite blends salty and sweet flavors with a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture that can provide cookie enthusiasts with a delightful twist on a classic pairing.

Sweet, dense, rich, and oh so satisfying! Our PB&J Cookie embodies that childhood favorite sandwich with an added bonus of our chunky house made Strawberry Jelly.

Disclaimer: These amazing cookies are made with natural Peanut Butter, oils may separate in transit.

Allergens

Wheat, Nuts, Dairy, Cornstarch, Soy, Eggs, Peanuts

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie Ingredients

Unbleached Enriched Wheat Flour, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Local Peanut Butter, House Made Strawberry Jelly (Strawberries, Sugar, Fruit Pectin), Local Butter, Local Free-Range Eggs, Locally Extracted Vanilla, Leavening (Aluminum Free Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Corn Starch) Himalayan Pink Salt.

Based on 1803 reviews
78%
(1408)
8%
(148)
7%
(119)
2%
(45)
5%
(83)
K
Custom Cookie Cake
Kendra Kleehammer

Love, love, love!

P
Choose Your Own Cookies
Patricia Kiphart
Great Gifts

I put my Taylor Chip cookies is gift bags, people are so impressed and cannot believe how big the cookies are. They taste great and the combos and choices are yummy it's hard to choose. I have ordered multiple times and will order again. Thank you Taylor Chip!

First time buyer

Cookies were delicious. Better when heated up. I only gave 4 stars because one of the cookies I chose wasn’t in my order. Instead, a duplicate cookie was put in

B
The Cookie Club
Bob Souer
They're telling the truth

Taylor Chip says that if it's not a Taylor Chip, it's just a cookie. That's some truth in advertising right there!

Best cookies ever

All flavors I ordered were fantastic!! Our son introduced us to your cookies 2 years ago when my husband was recovering from surgery.

Delicious

Great quality cookies

Lava cake cookie

The lava cake cookies are amazing and so good! They are very rich but so flavorful and I have to suggest warming them up it makes it that much better and Taylor chips customer service was top notch I had issues with a batch that I ordered not showing up and they did not hesitate to remake my order and send it back out the following day and even sent it out on 2 day shipping I will definitely be a returning customer Thanks Taylor Chip team!

Great gift

Everything went flawless and the cookies were awesome!

K
Choose Your Own Cookies
Kassie Watters
Cookies

We had a late delivery which was crummy but due to weather totally understand. I also bought the dozen but only received 11.. I took a video to have my son pick which one he wanted as he was not at the house. In the video it showed only 11.. but maybe one was taken before I was able to send my son a video to pick his own cookie…. But I’m sure there was only 11. Things happen. Still happy to help a small business grow. Cookies were shipped all the way to North Idaho :) thank you Taylor cookies. 🍪

Yummy in my tummy!

I love these cookies! They are the best of both worlds- firm on the outside and soft on the inside. I like to warm the cookie up for a few seconds in the microwave before eating. I know it may seem like an expensive cookie but each one is really like 4 cookies.

R
Choose Your Own Cookies
Robert D Gaudio
Fantastic

The cookies were fresh and among the best I've ever tasted. I'll definitely order again

M
Choose Your Own Cookies
Michele Saverko
Cookie order

Your cookies are delicious!!

Everything tasted great.

Every cookie was so good

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Christine Trycieckyj
Delicious!

My cookies arrived exactly when they were supposed to and they were nicely wrapped. Best of all, they were insanely delicious. We will definitely order again!

Better heated

Cookies were great once heated up !!!

m
Valentine’s Day Cookie Bundle
maureen townley
Valentines bundle

Sent this to my grandkids for valentines day. They absolutely loved it. It was the first time they had Taylor Chip and it won't be the last. I myself love Taylor Chip. Best cookies ever,

Awesome!!!!

I thoroughly enjoyed picking my favorites.

Taylor Chip cookies are decadent!! Love them!!!

Taylor Chip cookies are decadent!! Love them!!

Soooo Yummy!

These cookies were amazing!!! Everyone at the office thought they were amazing!! I'll be back.................I am back!!!

Little bit pricey, but really good and I don’t mind paying more to support a small business. Cookies arrived fresh, and arrived quick. Would purchase again.

The cookies in their packages did not look all that great to be honest. Some of them appeared better than others and the same was true for each cookie. Some of them were good and some of them were just okay! I would probably not order them again to be honest!

Sadly not impressed

Was excited to order and receive my Taylor chip cookies. However, when they got here, I wished I had never ordered! I did not receive the cookies that I ordered! And by that I mean the flavors I had chosen. Fine I get there may be shortages but I feel like I should have had a warning or a choice on substitutions. There was no notification in the box explaining so I was quite confused. The cookies themselves were honestly just OK.
I had seen a post from someone that was super excited to receive her order. In that order she had received several extra cookies. As a first time buyer, I thought how wonderful and that’s part of the reason why I ordered these expensive cookies. Well, no extra cookies and I didn’t get the cookies flavors I ordered.
Overall this was not a very good experience and I’m disappointed.

B
Choose Your Own Cookies
Brenda Chellew
Delicious

These are hands down the best cookies I’ve ever eaten. Haven’t tried one yet that I don’t love. They’re all wonderful.

Chocolate chip gift

The cookies were a gift and they said the chocolate chip cookies were the best they have ever had!