Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie

Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide
Slide

Description

When you’re craving the nostalgic combination of peanut butter and sweet fruit jam, our bakers craft the Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookie using creamy peanut butter and a generous swirl of raspberry jam, making certain that each bite blends salty and sweet flavors with a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture that can provide cookie enthusiasts with a delightful twist on a classic pairing.

Sweet, dense, rich, and oh so satisfying! Our PB&J Cookie embodies that childhood favorite sandwich with an added bonus of our chunky house made Strawberry Jelly.

Disclaimer: These amazing cookies are made with natural Peanut Butter, oils may separate in transit.

Allergens

Wheat, Nuts, Dairy, Cornstarch, Soy, Eggs, Peanuts

Peanut Butter & Jelly Cookie Ingredients

Unbleached Enriched Wheat Flour, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Local Peanut Butter, House Made Strawberry Jelly (Strawberries, Sugar, Fruit Pectin), Local Butter, Local Free-Range Eggs, Locally Extracted Vanilla, Leavening (Aluminum Free Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Corn Starch) Himalayan Pink Salt.

Based on 1530 reviews
79%
(1206)
8%
(127)
7%
(101)
2%
(36)
4%
(60)
Delicious!!

I took these cookies to my lab Christmas party and everyone loved them. The general consensus was Delicious!!

B
Choose Your Own Cookies
Brooke Rothenbuhler

Great cookies.

C
Choose Your Own Cookies
Colleen Coskren
Fabulous taste. Delivery destruction

Cookies have fabulous taste but damage to many of them during delivery made it impossible to use for a function dessert.

P
Choose Your Own Cookies
Peter Paajanen

wow

Great cookies!!

Wonderful cookies and great service. All of the flavors were delicious and I would order again.

T
Choose Your Own Cookies
Tony Creveling
Awesome Cookies

I love all the different varieties to choose from. While I have my favorites, all are made fresh and very flavorful. Love these cookies.

Sorry

I know it’s a busy time of year and you’re really really busy but I was really expecting better. Most of the cookies were hard and dry. The Cookies and cream and the PB fudge were ok. Sorry for the rest. Merry Christmas

Loved them all but the chocolate chip they were a little hard to chew.

Absolutely delicious!

I bought this box for my husband as a gift and they did not disappoint. Heat them a little bit and they are ah-mazing!

Delicious cookies!

Not only are they delicious, they're huge!

S
Choose Your Own Cookies
Susan Richmond
Best Cookie!!

Best cookie ever!! Fresh & delicious! Warmed in the microwave-incredible.

Awesome

Love them!

Loooooveeee themmmmm!

I love the variety! All of the cookies we've ordered have been wonderful

Yummy

Bought a dozen for me and another dozen as a gift. Cookies taste great and moist. Recommended for cookie lovers.

O
Holiday Cookie Bundle
Odyssey Martin

The cookies are a nicely sized. They were perfectly individually packed. These are Christmas gifts so super happy to try a few and give them out.

These are the best biggest cookies ever. I'm so glad I ordered. So worth it. Really enjoyed them.

Still the best

Great cookies, had em delivered all the way down here to Texas!

The cookies looked amazing but were much too sweet for my liking. It was difficult to taste anything other than sugar. The one exception was the chocolate lava cookie which was delicious with the dark chocolate being the boldest flavor.

L
Choose Your Own Cookies
LAURIE OGG BURNETT
Yummy

Best cookies ! Omg the ginger snap was to die for ❤️

J
Choose Your Own Cookies
Jennifer Wilson-Loving

Delicious & gooey!

Cookies were delicious

Quick, easy, and delicious. Worth every penny.

The best cookies

I live in California so these are always shipped to me. I get them within a week they're package very well, never broken. They are so yummy! I enjoy them as is but can be a little under cooked for some. You can put them in the oven for just a little bit and they cook a bit more and are like freshly baked cookies. Well worth the money.

Christmas gift